Downgraded water quality rating at Portobello Beach a ‘shocking wake-up call’ says MP
Mr Murray claimed SEPA has confirmed privately the primary pollutant at the beach is human waste.
An Edinburgh MP is demanding urgent action to clean up Portobello Beach after it was downgraded to “poor” by Scotland’s water quality regulator.
Portobello West is one of four bathing waters in Scotland to be classified as poor by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) in the regulator’s 2026 ratings, released earlier this week.


It is the first time Portobello West has been rated poor since 2017, after which is was consistently rated “sufficient”.
Chris Murray, the Scottish Labour MP for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh, said the results were “a shocking wake-up call” and demanded urgent action from the Scottish Government and Scottish Water.
SEPA said investigations at Portobello indicated pollution from sewage, gulls and dogs and said work to improve the water quality was underway given the popularity of the beach.
But Mr Murray claimed SEPA had confirmed privately the primary pollutant is human waste.
He said: “This beach is loved by local people in Porty, and is Scotland's most-visited beach, and they should be able to swim there without wondering whether it's filled with human waste.
“This summer it was closed with E. coli at ten times the safe limit, and I've lost count of the wet wipes and sanitary products I've picked up there at litter picks.
“This is completely unacceptable, and Scottish Water and the Scottish Government should be ashamed. It is their job to clean up our beach, and they should get to work.”
Mr Murray has also launched a petition calling for a ban on bonuses for Scottish Water executives while sewage pollution continues to affect local beaches.
It comes after water company executives received more than £250,000 in bonuses over the last year.
“This is a publicly owned company and answerable to Scottish ministers, so why haven't they stopped these outrageous payments?” he said.


Portobello residents have also called for the downgraded rating to be a “wake up call” for the authorities.
Frazer Lang of Porty Water Collective, said: "Although saddened by the news of the new classification, we are not surprised.
“Our continued testing, which carries on after the SEPA bathing water season tests stop, also shows repeatedly high levels of E. coli and faecal matter entering the sea from the Figgate Burn, which can only be coming from sewage outflows or misconnections.
“We are also discouraged that these consistently elevated levels continue to be blamed on gulls and dogs, which is patently ludicrous, and call for both Scottish Water and SEPA to take more ownership of the situation."
Sophie Eastwood of Porty Community Energy said: “Our community has been concerned about the health of our sea for a long time, and this should be a wake-up call.
“Porty's sea is at the heart of our community, used every day by so many, as well as being home to wildlife.
“We need to see real, urgent action to improve water quality to protect the sea for both people and nature."
A Scottish Water spokesperson said: “We would, as always, urge our customers to play their part and help prevent blockages and sewer flooding by avoiding flushing the wrong things down toilets, such as wet wipes and sanitary products.
“At Portobello (West), lower water quality is closely linked to heavy rainfall and evidence suggests there are contributions from multiple sources, not all linked to Scottish Water’s sewers.
“Scottish Water has invested £1 million in detailed studies, modelling and investigations to help us better understand and address sources of pollution from our networks affecting nearby watercourses.
“Our investigations have identified a number of misconnections, where household wastewater pipes have been incorrectly connected to the surface water network, and we will work with the relevant property owners to have these corrected.
“Work is continuing to investigate other potential sources of pollution and to assess the broader performance of our wastewater infrastructure, so that any further action or investment can be targeted where the evidence shows it would have the greatest benefit."
A spokesperson for SEPA said: “Scottish Water is carrying out a detailed pollution investigation across the catchment to identify and address pollution from sources such as sewer blockages and property misconnections.
“Any pollution issues identified through this investigation will be addressed as quickly as possible. Scottish Water is also undertaking a comprehensive hydraulic and water quality modelling study across the wider Portobello catchment.
“This £1 million study, due to conclude in early 2027, will identify potential infrastructure improvement projects for consideration within future investment programmes.
“SEPA are reviewing dry-weather spill performance and continuing to ensure that licensed infrastructure operates in compliance with environmental requirements and engaging with NatureScot and other partners on wider strategic approaches to managing gull-related impacts.
“The City of Edinburgh Council is continuing work to reduce the impacts of dog fouling, littering and the feeding of gulls, all of which can contribute to bacterial contamination reaching the bathing water.”
