Water quality at Edinburgh’s Portobello Beach downgraded to ‘poor’ by environmental regulator
Portobello Beach was forced to close to bathers during the summer due to e-coli levels ten times above the safe limit
Scotland’s environmental regulator has downgraded the bathing waters at Edinburgh’s Portobello Beach to “poor” for the first time in nine years after it failed to meet the required water quality standard.
Portobello West is one of four bathing waters in Scotland to be classified as poor by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) in the regulator’s 2026 ratings. Portobello Central has been rated “sufficient”.
It is the first time Portobello West has been rated poor since 2017, after which is was consistently rated “sufficient”. Dunbar East has also been downgraded to poor for the first time.
In the summer, Portobello Beach was forced to close to bathers after E. coli levels reached ten times the safe limit.
SEPA said investigations at Portobello indicated pollution from sewage, gulls and dogs and said work to improve the water quality was underway given the popularity of the beach.
At Dunbar East, the regulator said gull fouling, as well as changes to beach conditions including sand loss and seaweed accumulation, had contributed to deteriorating water quality.
SEPA’s annual bathing water classifications aim to reflect the long-term picture of water quality across Scotland, and are calculated using four years' of monitoring results - unlike individual water samples which show conditions at a particular point in time.


Local MP Chris Murray is campaigning for urgent action to address polluted waters in the area, and in September launched a petition calling for Scottish Water executive bonuses to be scrapped amid mounting anger over sewage spills.
At the time, he said residents had “every right to be angry” and said they have been “let down” by the lack of action to combat sewage pollution.
Dr Ruth Stidson, Principal Scientist for Bathing Waters at SEPA, said: “Most of Scotland's bathing waters continue to meet the required standards, and that's encouraging. But we know that for people who care about their local beach, the national picture isn't the whole story.
“Where water quality isn't good enough, people rightly want to understand why and what's being done about it. Improving bathing water quality can be complex. Pollution doesn't always come from one obvious source, and what works at one location won't necessarily work somewhere else.
A spokesperson for Scottish Water said: “At Portobello (West), lower water quality is closely linked to heavy rainfall and evidence suggests there are contributions from multiple sources, not all linked to Scottish Water’s sewers.
“Scottish Water has invested £1 million in detailed studies, modelling and investigations to help us better understand and address sources of pollution from our networks affecting nearby watercourses.
“Our investigations have identified a number of misconnections, where household wastewater pipes have been incorrectly connected to the surface water network, and we will work with the relevant property owners to have these corrected.
“Work is continuing to investigate other potential sources of pollution and to assess the broader performance of our wastewater infrastructure, so that any further action or investment can be targeted where the evidence shows it would have the greatest benefit.”
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “At Portobello, Scottish Water is undertaking a £1 million project to protect and potentially improve the water quality. This work includes detailed modelling and a “find and fix” watercourse pollution study to identify and mitigate sources of pollution as they are identified, such as misconnections.”
