Council’s inertia is its biggest problem in resolving issues - Edward Thornley

Last week I went to a public meeting in my ward arranged by our local MSP Alex Cole-Hamilton. The topic – the unauthorised encampments of the gypsy/traveller community which have increased in size and frequency in the west of the city over the past five years.

It was a fascinating meeting and I learned a lot. We heard from members of the traveller community and the settled residents affected by the encampments, and as is often the way, the conversation was a far more respectful and understanding than some had feared it could have been.

Drum Brae/Gyle councillor Ed Thornleyplaceholder image
Drum Brae/Gyle councillor Ed Thornley

If there was a consensus in the meeting from settled residents and the traveller representatives,it was a simple one – space where gypsy/travellers can halt, with access to waste collection, toilets and the like and without occupying a public space or park, is what is needed.

Edinburgh has a permanent, managed site with the facilities the community needs at North Cairntow, but it is full and the waiting list is long. A previous site in Midlothian, Whitecraig, has not reopened after Covid.

Travellers returned to Drum Brae Park in Edinburgh in September despite the council erecting barriers to keep them outplaceholder image
Travellers returned to Drum Brae Park in Edinburgh in September despite the council erecting barriers to keep them out

In June last year, the council agreed to begin work towards finding a new site, but thus far that is all. The meeting heard how planning systems have to be considered and land allocation is difficult outwith that process – and I understand that. Yet all the while, a situation that all communities agree is not sustainable continues.

The council representative at the meeting took a number of smaller, simpler actions away to look into, but to be fair they could not make any commitments on a timeline for a site.

Edinburgh Council is a lumbering behemoth, choked in process and red tape. Much of that is legislation from government but some is self-made.

Now I won’t pretend that the council can free itself of the shackles of national planning legislation, but surely it must be within the realms of possibility to move more quickly than this.

We saw this earlier in the year when the city centre ground to a halt following the fire on Princes Street. It was right that making the building safe was the number one priority, but should it really have knocked out access to our main public transport thoroughfare for over a month, at the busiest time of Edinburgh’s year?

Liberal Democrat councillors secured more money for road safety than ever at the budget the year before last, but where is the wave of long-awaited pedestrian crossings that it could have delivered? Certainly communities like Clerwood in my own ward are still waiting.

Grand strategies and ambitious plans are all well and good and the council has plenty of them. Yet how can the people of Edinburgh believe they will come to pass when delivering even the small stuff can tie the council up for years?

Until that inertia can be tackled, I don’t blame residents for their lack of faith.

Edward Thornley is councillor for Drum Brae/Gyle and Lib Dem Group Leader​

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice