Councils like Edinburgh need more powers to discourage car use, election hustings told

Councils like Edinburgh and Glasgow need more powers to help achieve a shift away from car use, Green councillor Chas Booth told an election hustings meeting organised by cycle campaign group Spokes.

He called for the use of "demand management" tools like a congestion charge and workplace parking levy.

And he attacked the "bureaucratic nightmare" of Traffic Regulation Orders (TROs) for slowing down many active travel projects.

Transport convener Stephen Jenkinson says councils don’t currently have the power to introduce a congestion charge. Picture: Lisa Ferguson.placeholder image
Transport convener Stephen Jenkinson says councils don’t currently have the power to introduce a congestion charge. Picture: Lisa Ferguson.

Representatives of Labour, the SNP, Conservatives and Lib Dems, as well as the Greens, attended the hustings ahead of the Scottish Parliament elections on May 7.

Asked if a congestion charge should be introduced, Edinburgh transport convener Stephen Jenkinson, for Labour, said: "No - we don't actually have the powers to implement a congestion charge. We've asked the Scottish Government a number of times to clarify the legislation and allow us to further the conversation, but at the moment we don’t have the legislative powers so we're very much in a holding pen on that particular policy."

Cllr Booth said there was a consensus between Edinburgh and Glasgow that powers of demand management were needed.

He said: "Without discouraging people from using the least sustainable modes of transport, we're not going to get that modal shift. But Scottish Government research shows it can meet its targets if it does use demand management, so that means congestion charge, workplace parking levy - which ideally s not just about workplaces, but non-domestic parking places. It's about discouraging people from using their cars, making them think 'Is there abetter way of making this journey?'"

And he said: "It's absolute lunacy that you can get permission to build 49 houses in Edinburgh within eight weeks, but if you want to build a tiny little section of cycle route the TRO will take you months, possibly even years. we need a root and branch reform of the bureaucratic system."

The SNP's Kate Campbell said she was "so disappointed" that Edinburgh had not introduced a workplace parking levy. "[It would have been] £10 million a year at least coming straight in that we can spend in watever way we want to, and it's a demand management tool - we would see a reduction in car use. These are the kind of chices that are made at local level that we need to really hold our councils to account for."

And she said planning decisions also influenced demand for private transport.

“Developers are still building homes with driveways, they are not putting in public transport and they're expecting people to drive in, so it’s up to cities to make the decision on how they're going to manage that.

"We need to think about how to make it a little bit less attractive for people to use their cars but also how do we make it a lot easier for people not to use their cars."

She also said TROs were on a little list of things she “really wanted to change” if she became an MSP.

However, Conservative Jo Mowat challenged Cllr Campbell's claim on workplace parking levy. She said: "If it's successful you don't get £10m a year continuing - you get that in the first year, then it goes steadily down. Is this a source of income or is it about demand management?

"I wouldn't introduce a WPL because it's putting extra pressure on business, ditto the congestion charge."

And she said it was too “convenient” for councils to attack the TRO process. “Yes, it takes a long time to get a TRO through in Edinburgh, but we only have two officers doing it. Double the size of the team and we might increase the speed of delivery.”

Sally Pattle, for the Lib Dems, said that 20 years ago she was living in Seville in the south of Spain, then one of the most polluted city centres in Europe. But the council there had pursued a radical plan.

“They banned traffic from the city centre, pedestrianised it, put in a tram system and the most fabulous network of cycle lanes - and they did it within three years. The opposition to that plan in 2005 was unbelievable, but by 2009 everyone loved their lovely new clean city and the tram system and they totally adopted cycle paths. That is what we need here.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice