Dundas relative hits out at plaque 'farce' after replacement installed at Edinburgh monument

It's claimed the council was “engaged in a battle against historical accuracy”.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

A descendant of Henry Dundas involved in removing an “inaccurate” plaque from the Melville Monument says his row with the council has “descended into farce” after a new one was installed.

Bobby Dundas’ Melville Monument Committee (MMC) took the plaque off the base of the statue last September after he dismissed the inscription’s claim his controversial ancestor was “instrumental” in delaying abolition of the slave trade as “cartoonishly inaccurate”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The council replaced the brass plate this week and said it would seek to recover the cost from the MMC.

Reacting, Mr Dundas said the local authority’s “five-year fixation” on the legacy of the prominent 18th century politician had “descended into farce”.

He said no request had been received to pay for the plaque and was “confident the city has no claim”.

“The plaque is a joke. Most people who follow the controversy know that now.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“The plaque presumes that Henry Dundas and his government could have ended all British slave trading, all at once, overnight, with a single enactment in 1792, and not a single slave would have been trafficked to the Caribbean after that day.

“This is ludicrous.  Eminent historians from around the world, including anti-Dundas historians, agree that such a result was impossible.”

Dundas relative hits out at plaque 'farce' after replacement installed on monument Dundas relative hits out at plaque 'farce' after replacement installed on monument
Dundas relative hits out at plaque 'farce' after replacement installed on monument

Mr Dundas said the council was “engaged in a battle against historical accuracy” and added: “They may have restored the plaque but they have lost all credibility and respect – with historians and more importantly, with the public.”

Meanwhile the police are continuing to investigate “a report of a theft from a monument in St Andrew Square, Edinburgh”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Edinburgh Council leader Cammy Day said as the new plaque was installed on Monday, March 18: “Since the original plaque was stolen last September, I’ve been clear that we will not allow the actions of a minority to derail the important ongoing work to address the legacies of slavery and colonialism in our city.

“Following the refusal of the Melville Monument Committee to return the original plaque, we filed an official report with Police Scotland in October. This investigation is ongoing, and our legal team will continue to monitor the situation closely.

“We’ll also be seeking to recover the costs of this replacement plaque from the Melville Monument Committee.”

However Mr Dundas said Cllr Day “and his cronies” had ignored “peer reviewed academic recommendations” which contradicted the plaque’s inscription.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“It’s disheartening to witness individuals in positions of ‘power’ abusing their authority so blatantly and negligently. Over the span of five years, they haven’t consulted any genuine, respected, reputable historians for their perspective,” he said.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.