Edinburgh council leader Jane Meagher accuses Scottish Government of 'insult to local democracy'

‘Just nine weeks left to consider future of local democracy in Scotland’

Edinburgh council leader Jane Meagher has branded the Scottish Government's approach to the proposed shake-up of Scotland's councils "an insult to local democracy".

The government is in talks with council leaders about plans to replace the current 32 councils with between six and 10 regional authorities and between 120 and 160 community authorities.

First Minister John Swinney has set a three-month timetable for "intensive conversation" on local government reform.

But the government’s "initial proposition" was only put on paper after council leaders asked for a clear statement.

Cllr Meagher said at the first meeting between Mr Swinney and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorites (Cosla) - which took place online - the First Minister had set aside just half an hour for the talks with council leaders.

Jane Meagher has branded the Scottish Government's approach as 'an insult to democracy'placeholder image
Jane Meagher has branded the Scottish Government's approach as 'an insult to democracy' | Submitted

She said: "At that meeting, when people asked what was on the table, basically he said 'It's all in my head'. We said 'Can you tell us what's in your head?' and that resulted 10 days later in this paper."

A Cosla meeting on Friday urged caution over the government's plans and called for strong evidence to underpin any significant changes, adding that at the moment there were more questions than answers.

Cllr Meagher said: "This is one of the most important potential changes in local government for decades and it's all being done hastily, on a shoestring and without any clear method of consultation.

"It's an insult to local democracy. There may be opportunities in there, but because everything is so unclear it's hard to see where those opportunities lie.

"Now we're down to about nine weeks to consider the future of local democracy in Scotland."

She has warned the shake-up plans would likely mean Edinburgh council would cease to exist.

And she asked: “What’s going to happen about council tax? Will these small community authorities get to keep whatever council tax is raised in their area or will the regional authorities decide how to disperse council tax across the area? There are so many far-reaching questions there just isn’t an answer to.”

Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth attended the initial meeting with Cosla, along with Mr Swinney.

In an interview with the BBC’s Sunday Show at the weekend, she said: “We didn't come to this with an initial plan, we came back to Cosla at an ask they gave to the First Minister and I at a meeting we held with them back on September 11, and in that meeting Cosla were very clear they wanted to see proposals from the government, so we have come forward with some draft proposals.”

And she defended the short timescale for the talks. She said: “We have quite deliberately set quite a tight time period of three months, which will take us roughly to the beginning of December.

“We have done that quite deliberately because I think there is an urgency required around local government reform. If you speak to folk in our local communities, they've got really strong views about their council services and rightly so. So we need to move at pace to improve the availability of local services.”

Ms Gilruth said the government wanted to reach a “shared position” with Cosla. But she added: “This can’t just be a conversation between Scottish Government and local government. We’ve got to engage the public in this. Public engagement in local government reform will be key.

“We'll be working on a number of ways in which we'll be doing that in the coming months to make sure people's views are captured and are reflected in the reforms that we take forward.”

Council leaders and chief executives are due to meet ministers again on Wednesday.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice