Edinburgh MSP Ash Regan urges MSPs not to 'fail another generation of women' by rejecting her Prostitution Bill

Edinburgh Eastern independent MSP Ash Regan has urged MSPs not to “fail another generation of vulnerable women and children” by throwing out her Bill criminalising the buying of sex.

She spoke out after the Scottish Parliament’s criminal justice committee reported it could not reach a consensus on whether to endorse the general principles of the Bill.

The committee was evenly split, with two Labour and two Conservative MSPs saying the proposed legislation should proceed to the next stage of the parliamentary process, while four SNP MSPs said it should not go any further than the Stage 1 vote scheduled for February 3.

Ash Reganplaceholder image
Ash Regan | PA

Ms Regan - who was SNP community safety minister before she resigned over gender recognition reform - said her Bill was SNP party policy.

And she said: "Supporting the idea of criminalising sex buying while refusing to legislate is simply not good enough. Women do not need warm words; they expect MSPs to have political courage and act on principle.

“If the SNP truly believes that prostitution is a form of violence against women, then it must not shield the perpetrators of that violence from the law, or the public will rightly ask why?"

Ms Regan said her Bill had attracted strong and serious support from across the parliament, including from SNP MSPs.

“Cross-party backing reflects what the Scottish public, women's organisations, frontline services, and survivors have consistently told us: criminalising sex buyers is essential if we are to tackle exploitation and male violence against women and girls.”

As well as creating a new criminal offence of paying for a sexual act, with those convicted facing fines of up to £10,000 and possible jail time, the Bill would also repeal the existing offence of loitering, soliciting or importuning in a public place for the purposes of prostitution. Those found guilty of this offence in the past would have their convictions quashed; and those trying to leave prostitution would be given the right to support.

Ms Regan continued: "Despite the explicit backing of my Unbuyable Bill from Police Scotland, the Crown Office, COSLA, frontline support services and most critically, brave survivors of prostitution, the long-delayed report from the committee considering my Bill is split.

"What the public will be most shocked by is that the four committee members who do not support the principles of my Bill at Stage 1 are members of my former party, the SNP - the same SNP that, for years, has gone on record in the Scottish Parliament supporting the principle of criminalising the purchase of sex.

“When I was the Minister for Community Safety, this Bill was in the Government's own five-year program for this session. What has changed?

“It appears that, when it comes to turning promises into action, commitments are quietly abandoned when it comes to protecting women and girls.

“I am shocked that the SNP would again fail another generation of vulnerable women and children, leaving them to the mercy of the trade in commercial sexual exploitation.

“Protecting sex buyers is a decision. I doubt any MSP could look a survivor of prostitution in the eye and explain their choice to do nothing - again, while making more promises, with their fingers crossed behind their backs.

"In the final weeks of this Parliament, it is time for politicians to stop hiding behind contradiction, process and delay. Anything less than action is rank hypocrisy, and failure of both survivors and the next generation to face harm; they deserve better."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice