Edinburgh speeding: Community volunteers could be trained to use speed guns in scheme advocated by Greens

Members of the public could be trained to use speed guns to catch motorists who are driving too fast, under a scheme advocated by Edinburgh’s Green councllors.

They say speeding is a frequent factor in road deaths but the police are not doing enough to enforce sped limits.

And they claim one answer could be Community Speedwatch, a national initiative where volunteers in local communities are supported by the police to monitor speeds of vehicles, using speed detection devices.

A speed gun in operation as part of the Community Speewatch scheme in Mansfield, Nottinghamshireplaceholder image
A speed gun in operation as part of the Community Speewatch scheme in Mansfield, Nottinghamshire

The volunteers dress in high visibility clothing and record details of speeding vehicles - registration numbers, speeds, dates, and times - which are then passed to the police, who issue warning letters. Repeat offenders can face prosecution based on collected evidence.

A Community Speedwatch scheme has been trialled in Fife and similar schemes are well established in several areas in England.

Green councillor Chas Booth successfully proposed at the last meeting of Edinburgh’s transport committee that officials should look at whether Community Speedwatch could be explored in Edinburgh.

Community Speedwatch volunteers in action in West Sussexplaceholder image
Community Speedwatch volunteers in action in West Sussex

He said: “According to road safety charity Brake, excessive speed is a contributory factor in one in three fatal road collisions. And we also know that higher speeds lead to exponentially worse outcomes, in particular for vulnerable road users: those walking, wheeling or cycling; children and young people, disabled people and older people.”

He argued that in the absence of better enforcement of speed limits by the police, trained volunteers was an option that should be explored.

Cllr Booth highlighted a report by HM Inspectorate of Constabulary which noted the number of people killed or seriously injured on Scotland’s roads had increased each year since 2020 and said shrinking police resources meant road policing was likely to have received less focus.

The report also said there was a strong perception that road policing is a low priority for Police Scotland.

Cllr Booth said the council should “take a lead” on tackling speeding, by ensuring that roads and footways were designed and maintained to discourage speeding and minimise the risk of collision. And he said it should also stick to a pledge to discourage car use.

“So the best way to tackle speeding would be for the council administration to stick to its transport pledges. The second best way would be for Police Scotland to do their jobs and enforce the speed limit effectively - but as recent reports on road policing by the police inspectorate have made clear, that simply isn't happening.

“In the absence of effective measures to tackle speeding from the police, the council should explore alternatives to tackle the issue. Community speedwatch is one such initiative, which has worked in other parts of the country and could work in Edinburgh too.

“It's certainly not an alternative to effective enforcement to crack down on dangerous drivers, but if it can make our streets safer and save a single life lost on our roads, then it's worth considering."

Critics of such schemes have claimed they amount to the police encouraging citizens to spy on each other. One letter to a national newspaper said: “It's not difficult to see where schemes like Community Speedwatch lead: vigilantism, score settling and a breakdown in trust between people.”

And on social media, volunteers have been labelled "do-gooders" and "grasses".

Others argue the only answer is for he police to be better funded.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice