Edinburgh's Marionville fire station faces even more uncertainty as budget shortfall adds to problems

Edinburgh's fire services - already facing the proposed closure of Marionville fire station - are now under threat from 'devastating' further cuts due to a shortfall in Scottish Government funding.

Residents, politicians and the Fire Brigades Union have been campaigning for months to save Marionville, which has been earmarked for closure as part of a Scotland-wide review by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS).

A decision was due before Christmas, but now chief fire officer Stuart Stevens has told MSPs a final decision will not be made until after the Holyrood elections in May.

Marionville fire station is earmarked for closure by the SFRSplaceholder image
Marionville fire station is earmarked for closure by the SFRS

And Mr Stevens also warned the Scottish Government's budget allocation to the SFRS - an £18m increase rather than the £30m he said was needed - could result in cuts to firefighter numbers. He said the budget gap could mean having to lose 517 firefighters over the next three years, on top of the 166 firefighters who could go as part of the review.

David Strachan, FBU branch secretary at Marionville, said: "The budget given to us by the Scottish Government is absolutely horrendous for the service.

"We are looking at hundreds of firefighter posts across the country having to be stripped out of the organisation, as well as even more station closures than were originally proposed because the government budget falls so far short of what is required.

"It is unequivocal that Edinburgh will be facing frontline cuts because the cuts will have to come from right across the service."

On the delayed review, Mr Strachan said: "Morale is at an all time low within the service, particularly those stations potentially affected by the proposals. It's very, very uncertain times for us. Of course it's good that the SFRS are taking time to make sure they analyse all of the data. But with regard to the delay itself, it's just further uncertainty.

"The chief fire officer has said that the review's original intention was to distribute services to where they're needed most. However he has made it clear this is now a package of frontline cuts and it will damage public safety and firefighter safety."

One of the concerns about the proposed closure of Marionville is that it would increase the time it takes for a fire engine to get to the scene of a fire. The SFRS has acknowledged slower response times are likely, which in a "worst case scenario" could mean an extra 4-6 minutes. But it says response times in the Marionville area would then be similar to those for lots of other areas in the city.

Giving evidence to MSPs at the same meeting as the chief fire officer, the FBU’s John McKenzie warned a reduction in firefighters as a result of the budget gap would also slow response times.

He said: “Between 2014 to 2024, response times increased by an average of a minute and a half. The timeframe has gone from about six minutes and 50 seconds to about eight minutes and 20 seconds, which is really significant.

“I do not say this to overdramatise it but, in a variety of instances, increasing response times will mean the difference between life and death, or the difference between firefighters’ being able to make interventions and people becoming seriously hurt.”

It is unclear what direct impact the new financial situation will have on the review and the future of Marionville.

Closure of Marionville is part of a wider proposal which would also transfer the Marionville fire engine to Newcraighall, close Musselburgh fire station and move its engine to a relocated Tranent station.

One source said: “The SFRS may now not have enough money to build a new station in Tranent, which means they might not be able to close Tranent or Musselburgh, so that option may well fall because they can't afford to do what they wanted to do.

“However, another possibility is they could prioritise that option because it would result in the closure of three fire stations and they only have to build one."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice