Residents voice fears over closure of Edinburgh's Marionville fire station
Residents have voiced fears about response times and public safety if Edinburgh's Marionville fire station is closed.
After fire chiefs outlined their shake up plans at a public meeting, local people said they believed the closure would put them at increased risk.
The proposals would see Marionville close and its fire engine transfer to Newcraighall, where it could still be deployed to fires in Edinburgh. Musselburgh fire station would also close, with its fire engine moving to a relocated Tranent fire station.


The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) estimates average response times in the area covered by Marionville would increase from 4-6 minutes to 6-8 minutes.
But one woman said: "Every second counts when it comes to fires. It defies logic to say public safety isn't at risk. How can the SFRS say public risk isn't increasing?"
And another woman referred to the £1.1m which the SFRS expects to get for selling the three sites at Marionville, Musselburgh and Tranent. She asked: "What makes you think that's a fair cost for increasing risk for people? And why haven't you lobbied the government around these cuts and get them to give the money we need to keep Marionville open?"
The SFRS has said the proposals - part of a Scotland-wide shake-up are not cost-driven and in Edinburgh represent not a cut, but a redistribution of resources which will best meet current needs.


Assistant Chief Fire Officer David Farries told the meeting at Craigentinny community centre: "The changes we are looking at here have been discussed in the past under different financial times and are currently our proposal because it's the right thing to do."
He acknowledged £1.1m did not seem a lot of money for the sale of three sites, but said it was a conservative estimate and whatever money was raised would be reinvested into the service.
And he added: "It's not about looking for additional money to save Marionville because we don't believe our position is financially driven - we" think it's the best plan regardless of the financial element."
Craigentinny/Duddingston Green councillor Alex Staniforth was among those expressing scepticism about how fast a fire engine could get from Newcraighall to Marionville.
He said he lived just west of Newcraighall. "I have to say at certain times of day those roads are simply a traffic jam. And the idea you could get quickly from Newcraighall to anywhere in the east of Edinburgh, even with a siren blaring, is just fiction."
Deputy Assistant Chief Officer Andy Girrity said Edinburgh had been busy for a long time. "Will traffic getting busier making it a bit more difficult? Yes, of course it will, but it's not going to add on an amount of time we would be unduly concerned about."
Edinburgh Northern & Leith SNP MSP Ben Macpherson said Maionville should be kept. He said: “There is widespread concern in the community and in this room tonight about those response times and I think those concerns are justified.
“We want people to get the response they need as soon as possible and we don't know, with all the population growth exactly how those response times are going to be affected by more buildings, busier roads, more demand.
"In this growing city we need to retain cover and build on it. We should at least keep Marionville open until we are clear what the population growth and what the response times are.”
Lothian Labour MSP Sarah Boyack, who was also at the meeting, had earlier raised Marionville’s proposed closure in the Scottish Parliament, highlighting climate change as another reason it should remain open.
She told fellow MSPs: “This summer we had a fire that burned for several days in Uphall in West Lothian. Just last month we had a serious fire in Holyrood Park that lasted for days. That is why we need to see the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service properly resourced to deal with the new risks of fire and flooding.
“Rural and urban communities will need more capacity not cuts. The time it takes firefighters to arrive can make the difference between life and death.
“So it makes no sense to close Marionville Fire Station, just over a mile from our Parliament. This is an area where 3,500 new homes are planned, where there are major developments at Leith Ports, and where Marionville is the station responsible for tackling fires in Holyrood Park. Closing Marionville would leave families, businesses, more exposed to risk. It makes no sense to close a station so vital to local communities.”