Holyrood elections 2026: Four teenagers give their views on key issues aired at hustings
Four pupils who attended a special hustings where 16-18 year-olds quizzed Edinburgh candidates on key issues offer their reflections on the event ahead of the Holyrood elections.
The hustings, under the banner The Future Speaks, were organised by James Gillespie’s High School and the Edinburgh Futures Institute.
And seven candidates answered the questions in front of an audience of around 100.


Charis Wright - Boroughmuir High School
It felt like many candidates had rehearsed stances on some issues like AI, but when it came to questions about biodiversity, they were floundering.
Most of the time they did not answer the question and went off on tangents about the economy, housing, or taxes - it's great to see they have policies set for those issues, but, that was not what the question was asking and not particularly relevant for teenagers currently.
For issues like phones and social media there were clear policies across the board of restrictions, but when it came to the issues of climate change only two parties had policies set in stone that would curb the impact of climate change and potentially change the future.
Some parties did not care about the issues we cared about. There was an apparent lack of research on certain topics and a lack of awareness of who was in the audience - teenagers.
Nevertheless I think everyone enjoyed learning more about policies they may put in place. I would like another young people’s hustings in the future with a wider spread of questions and topics such as education and misogyny.


Sira Johnston - Portobello High School
All in all, I found the hustings profoundly captivating and incredibly engaging. The candidates answered the thoughtful questions of the young people honestly, which is very important for those of us voting at the next election for whom climate change and sustainability is a primary concern.
And they went into detail regarding other important issues such as education, taxation, and agriculture which tie in incredibly closely with sustainability.
It gave me hope for politics: despite having vastly different views on nearly every topic, the candidates present were able to agree and disagree (mostly) respectfully, even coming to agreement in places where you would least expect it.
In my notes, “Agreed with Gary” is underlined and in capital letters, because I found it so wonderful that Kate Nevens of the Scottish Greens was able to find some level of common ground with Gary Neil of Reform Scotland - this was about the importance of a just transition of jobs from oil and gas to renewable energy.
As someone who deeply values tolerance and cooperation, I am truly glad that Edinburgh’s potential MSPs are setting the right example, for young people and for other politicians.
I believe it is events like this that will empower young people with the knowledge of politics needed to make well-informed voting decisions at the next election, as well as just becoming well-informed individuals.


Joy Grisewood - Portobello High School
The event gave an insight into the world of politics that so many of us teenagers will be entering soon via voting. I found it most helpful to gain an understanding of each party not only through their answers, but through the way they approached the questions.
As expected, many were evasive or talked for far too long without saying anything of value. But through witnessing which candidates used such tactics, and alternatively who acted with intention in their words and a genuine tone, I believe many of those present left with a better understanding into each parties’ methods and stance on important matters.
The questions - on AI, disinformation, oil and gas and food production - were of great interest to me and many of my peers. So, gaining an appreciation of each individual's viewpoint was thoroughly helpful.
However, when poverty was brought into the conversation it struck me that those in attendance were mostly from more affluent schools and areas of the city.
But perhaps my favourite part of the experience was witnessing how people with wildly differentopinions could happily mingle prior to the meeting commencing, finding something in common regardless of their opposing lifestyles.


Emmy Anagnostou - James Gillespie's High School
It wasn’t a surprise that so many questions focused on AI, considering the growing use of it despite its lack of sustainability and the ethical dilemmas surrounding it. It makes sense to want to know as much as possible about politicians’ opinions and future plans about it.
Most of the candidates were optimistic about the use of AI, believing it could be integrated into society and used in healthcare and education to enhance learning and help take pressure off of the NHS. However, Kate Nevens, of the Green Party, was firmly against the use of AI, for environmental reasons and the belief that it is making people less curious.
All of the parties were also in favour of growing the economy in a sustainable way – apart from Reform - but no-one offered a way to counter the negative environmental impact of it.
The SNP was for working with AI in schools and educating people in digital skills, but also were incredibly clear in saying that AI databases are estimated to use up huge amounts of energy and that this needed to be managed. But there was no suggestion of how to counter this impact or limit AI use - surely a crucial point to consider.
vbnm