Holyrood elections 2026: 'Voters were more interested in vibes and values than delivery'

Will Labour and Lib Dems work together in new session?

Delivery is usually held up by politicians as a top priority - governments bringing about change and doing what they promise.

But one new Labour MSP suggested at a conference last week that that's not what voters were interested in during the Holyrood elections’V.

Voters at a polling station in Edinburgh Central on May 7placeholder image
Voters at a polling station in Edinburgh Central on May 7 | TSPL

Katherine Sangster, elected for the Edinburgh and Lothians East region, said: "I think we're in a place with politics where I don't think people are particularly delivery-focused. They're voting on the basis of their values and their identity. We need to reflect how we ever get over that constitutional logjam."

Addressing the same event, Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy MP Melanie Ward agreed: "Kath is absolutely right - it seems that people care as much about the vibes you give off and your values as much as they do about how much you're going to bring down NHS waiting lists or make the ferries go on time."

Ahead of the election, academics noted that people's position for or against independence was the best guide to the way they were likely to vote. And with only one pro-independence party standing in all constituencies against four pro-UK parties, that helps explain the SNP ending up as by far the biggest party.

The conference, organised by Edinburgh University Business School and the Scottish Fabians think tank and sponsored by True North Advisors, looked back at the election campaign and forward to the new session of parliament.

Possible future co-operation between Labour and the Lib Dems was one theme explored.

New Lib Dem MSP David Green saw "a lot of common ground" but said there was also a challenge for Labour. "At the last two budgets, Lib Dems secured some big wins for the people who sent us to parliament and Labour has not engage with that budget process in the same way."

Re-elected Glasgow Labour MSP Paul Sweeney said there was "a lot of opportunity for Labour to exert a lot of leverage in this parliament" and he thought Labour and the Lib Dems could work intelligently to extract concessions from the government.

He suggested the increased Green group would "not be as coherent" as tthe previous one and similarly with Reform it was "difficult to see how they hang together".

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice