City Chambers is not the place for student politics - Iain Whyte

With a bursting agenda of 11 items needing decision, mostly with important financial implications, you would think the last council meeting of the year would be a chance to drop the juvenile virtue signalling this council has become known for.

Alas, the student politicians in the Chambers insist on carrying on regardless. This time it was a motion, submitted late for the agenda, calling for “solidarity” with Palestine Action hunger strikers. Thankfully, the Lord Provost ruled this wasn’t an “emergency” the council needed to discuss but don’t bet against it being resubmitted in future.

Robert Aldridge, Edinburgh's Lord Provost, in the gold and diamond chain of office. Picture: Greg Macveanplaceholder image
Robert Aldridge, Edinburgh's Lord Provost, in the gold and diamond chain of office. Picture: Greg Macvean

Over the past few years, we have seen loads of motions from far-left councillors putting forward their views on matters that are nothing to do with providing local council services.

Their national and international pet hates take up time at taxpayers’ expense. With a time cut off for council meetings, this regularly means matters with direct relevance to the city aren’t discussed.

This time the motion was particularly egregious, describing the accused as “political prisoners” and suggesting they are imprisoned for simple protest. But protest has it limits, and we are clear in the UK that it should remain peaceful.

These “protestors” are on remand while they are prosecuted for extremely serious and violent criminal offences. Their organisation has been proscribed under terrorism laws by a Labour Home Secretary, supported by Parliament.

Half of the hunger strikers are charged with breaking into RAF Brize Norton and causing millions of pounds of damage to UK military jets. The others are charged with aggravated burglary, criminal damage and violent disorder after breaking into a defence company premises where one protestor allegedly attacked a police sergeant with a sledgehammer.

No one should really be surprised that they have been placed on remand. This is normal court practice for severe offences and the courts also consider any risk that an accused might abscond or continue a campaign of criminal activity.

What is most annoying is that some of our local politicians think that taxpayer time and money should be spent “campaigning on the Council Tax” about issues with no council locus. This one isn’t even a UK matter.

Maybe the public should think more carefully about who they send to represent them in the City Chambers. Always ask your local politicians whether they will use their platform to concentrate on Edinburgh matters.

Conservative group leader, Edinburgh City Council

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice