Council’s response to EHRC’s guidance forgot to ask women - Susan Dalgety
Tomorrow, the council’s Policy and Sustainability Committee will consider a report on the Equality and Human Right Commission’s (EHRC) recently updated guidance on single-sex spaces.
To remind readers, last April the campaign group For Women Scotland won a landmark victory in the Supreme Court, when judges ruled unanimously that the terms "sex," "man," and "woman" in the Equality Act 2010 mean biological sex at birth.


This historic judgement means that all single-sex spaces provided by councils, such as toilets and changing rooms, must be based on biological sex and that all policies and service delivery – including signage – must be updated to abide by the law.
So far, so simple. But in Tuesday’s 14-page report (including two appendices), council officials have managed to make something straightforward seem as complex as solving the climate crisis.
And interestingly, while officers have gone to great lengths to respect the rights of “trans gender colleagues”, making them feel “safe” and “fully supported”, the rights of women barely rate a mention.
For Women Scotland and others have expressed concern that the report was produced without any input from women’s groups, while it goes to great lengths to stress how the council fosters a “culture of inclusion and understanding” and demonstrates its commitment to upholding the Equality Act by “challenging transphobia”.
And the council is so worried that transgender staff may experience bullying that it has decided to recruit an “individual skilled in trauma-informed approaches and all forms of discrimination and harassment.”
It is just a pity that Edinburgh City Council did not show the same duty of care to the girls forced to share their school toilets with boys in recent years. Or to the survivors of sexual assault and rape who were told to “reframe their trauma” by Mridul Wadhwa, the man who previously ran Edinburgh’s Rape Crisis Centre, funded by the city council.
Nor is there much mention of the rights of the council’s female employees, which at the last count make up more than 70 per cent of its workforce.
The report uses language associated with gender identity activists, such as “gender assigned at birth” (ie sex observed at birth), and sets out in great detail how “transgender and non-binary persons” will be looked after.
Perhaps the tone and the content of the report is unsurprising, however, given that the majority of councillors voted only a few weeks ago to condemn the updated EHRC guidance as “discriminatory against trans people, unworkable and potentially incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.”
And council leader Jane Meagher was instructed to write to the Prime Minister – with ‘help’ from opposition parties – to urge him to withdraw the guidance.
It seems there’s not much concern for the rights of women and girls among the city’s SNP, Liberal Democrat and Scottish Green councillors, who led on June’s motion.
Councillors would do well to remember that any reasonable estimate calculates that women make up the majority of the city’s electorate, at around 52 or 53 per cent, and are slightly more likely than men to vote.
There are only eight months and a bit until the next council elections on May 7. Women cannot wait.