Donald Anderson: Solving the problem of Westfield Court – not a thing of beauty

It’s not often my heart goes out to my former council colleagues and officers in the City Council, but it did when I heard of Historic Environment Scotland’s decision to raise the prospect of listing Westfield Court in Gorgie.

Westfield House, much like the distillery building that used to sit adjacent to the West Approach Road, is one of those buildings that you feel sucking the life from you as you go past. I’m not sure anyone has ever argued that it is a thing of beauty.

Westfield Court now has crash decks in case of falling claddingplaceholder image
Westfield Court now has crash decks in case of falling cladding

More than that, it is a monumental money pit with a huge array of defects that include potential ongoing running costs of £53,000 a month and include water ingress, plus sewage and waste pipe failures.

Most of the flats are in private ownership and owners either face a lengthy wait while the future of the building is considered, or an indetermined financial penalty to restore and stay in their flats.

Demolition doesn’t just look preferable, it looks like an open and shut case in my book, especially when the site could be redeveloped for nice new homes.

Edinburgh’s built heritage is rightly protected where buildings possess real architectural or historic merit, but it’s difficult to see that regarding Westfield House. And policy should also recognise where a building has become economically unviable and no longer meets the needs of the local community.

I do have a potential solution, though. Historic Environment funding is 50 per cent paid for by Edinburgh, or to be exact, Edinburgh Castle and paid visitors and events.

A lot of that money rightly comes back to protect and enhance Edinburgh’s unique world heritage sites and 4500 listed buildings, but most of it is redistributed across Scotland, for very good reasons.

Historic Environment Scotland could fund the restoration of Westfield House or at least consider whether that is a wise investment compared to the many other priorities for its funding.

I’m not sure that’s a sensible thing to do, as demolition looks to me as a layperson to be a no brainer, but it would be a solution.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice