Plans to turn Edinburgh New Town funeral parlour into serviced apartments refused due to impact on neighbours
Plans rejected despite strong support from local community to secure building’s future
Plans to turn an Edinburgh New Town funeral parlour into serviced apartments have been refused due to an 'unacceptable impact on the neighbouring amenity'.
Bluemarsh Ltd submitted plans in March for a change of use and alterations to a former funeral directors/ parlour to create seven serviced apartments, with integral manager’s accommodation, at 39 London Street.
Those proposals were rejected by council planners on September 17, with the council’s chief planning officer David Givan stating: “The change of use of this property to serviced apartments for short term let use will have an unacceptable impact on neighbouring amenity.


“Whilst it is recognised that there is an economic benefit to the city as a whole from the provision of tourist accommodation, in this case it does not outweigh the adverse impact on residential amenity.
“The proposal does not comply with the Development Plan. There are no material considerations that outweigh this conclusion. The proposal is unacceptable.”
The ground floor ceased operations approximately 15 years ago and the two lower floors some 35 years ago. The property has been in a state of disrepair since. The planning documents include recent photos of the site, which show just how much work would need to be done internally to get the building operational again.


While there were four objections to the plans from locals, there were 38 notes of support from the local community.
One of the local residents in support of the change of use application said: “Having considered both the previous refusal and the revised proposal, it is clear that the key concerns identified by the council have now been directly and effectively addressed.
“The introduction of permanent 24-hour on-site management represents a fundamental change in how the development will operate. The presence of staff at all times ensures that the property will be actively supervised, with clear accountability and immediate response to any issues that may arise.
“In my view, the previous reasons for refusal have now been resolved, and there are no longer any sound planning grounds on which to resist the application. I therefore strongly support the proposal and respectfully request that consent is granted.”
Another supporter of the plans added: “The proposed scheme offers a sensitive and viable route to securing the building's future. By introducing a sustainable and economically viable use, the development ensures that the building will be maintained, repaired, and actively cared for.”
However, one of the neighbouring residents objected to the plans for various reasons, including them contradicting the Local Development Plan, increased noise and activity at the address, the plans not being in keeping with the surrounding area, and the scale of the proposed changes.
They added: “If the units are intended for short-term letting, the proposal falls squarely within the policy concerns that have led Edinburgh Council to refuse a substantial proportion of short-term let applications in recent years, particularly where the council considers the proposal to conflict with its housing objectives.”


Internal and external works associated with the change of use were assessed in the concurrent listed building consent application, which was granted earlier this month.
The change of use would have created seven serviced units for the purpose of short term let use over three floors. A reception area was to be created to the right on the ground floor.
There was to be four apartments on the ground floor, two at basement level and one unit plus a manager's suite on the sub-basement level. Each of the seven STL units would have had one double bedroom, kitchenette, and separate en-suite bathroom.
For the latest public notices from your area, please visit: https://publicnoticeportal.uk/
