'This confirms Scottish Government's proposed mansion tax really amounts to a tax on Edinburgh' says MSP

Answers by Finance Secretary Shona Robison when she was quizzed by MSPs on the proposed so-called mansion tax confirm that the SNP is planning a "tax on Edinburgh", a city MSP has claimed.

Labour's Daniel Johnson said Ms Robison's evidence to Holyrood's finance committee showed that while most of the money raised by the creation of two new council tax bands on homes worth over £1 million would come from Edinburgh, the Scottish Government wanted the cash to be spread to councils all across the country.

"The tax will be levied in Edinburgh, but spent everywhere else," he said.

Finance Secretary Shona Robison giving evidence to Holyrood's finance committeeplaceholder image
Finance Secretary Shona Robison giving evidence to Holyrood's finance committee | screenshot

And he claimed Edinburgh would be left to fight its own corner in a "bun fight" with the rest of Scotland's 32 councils over the distribution.

Ms Robison announced the mansion tax plan in the Scottish Budget on January 13, saying that two new council bands would be introduced for the most expensive properties in Scotland, those worth more than £1 million on an up-to-date valuation.

And she hailed the move as "a measure that will bring greater fairness as well as increased revenues to councils".

But last week, Mr Johnson - MSP for Edinburgh Southern - said most of the properties hit by the new tax would be in or around the Capital. And he said: "It is hard to avoid the conclusion that this will be a tax on Edinburgh.”

Giving evidence at the finance committee on Tuesday, Ms Robsion was asked by Glasgow MSP John Mason what would happen to the revenue raised by the extra two bands.

She replied: "Ultimately that is going to be something that Cosla (Convenion of Scottish Local Authorities) will need to decide upon.

"There is the option for Cosla to decide on a distribution formula which means that, rather than just the authorities that make the most money from those two additional bands keeping the money and no-one else gets, there is the alternative for Cosla and local government to agree a distribution formula around that.

"But that isn't for me to dictate, that would be for them to decide among themselves, though that won't be without its difficulties.

"The one principle, though, is that, unlike the UK government who took money into the centre, we have agreed the principle that the money will be retained by local government, but it's then how it is retained by local government that is the issue.

"It won't take effect before 1 April 2028, so there is scope and time for local government to discuss and agree these matters."

Mr Johnson questioned why a decision would be left to Cosla alone. But he said: "It confirms what we feared - that essentially this tax will be raised in Edinburgh and distributed everywhere else.

"But what's more, it sounds like Edinburgh will be forced into a room with 31 other local authorities and take part in what seems to be little better than a bun fight between local authorities to figure out who gets to spend money raised in Edinburgh.

"What this shows is this is a policy that has been made on the hoof, but it underlines the intent of the SNP government to tax Edinburgh and spend that everywhere else.

"In effect it will be distributed by a bun fight and Edinburgh having to fight its own corner among 31 other local authorities."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice