11 Hearts pundits react to Scottish Cup defeat vs Aberdeen including Beaton pop and John Robertson verdict

Here’s how the Hearts pundits reacted to the club’s Scottish Cup semi final defeat vs Aberdeen

The Hearts pundits have been out in force after a 2-1 Scottish Cup semi final loss vs Aberdeen.

Pape Habe Gueye put the Dons ahead before a Lawrence Shankland leveller. Michael Steinwender was sent off for the Jambos but Neil Critchley’s men matched or bettered Aberdeen in large elements of a game that spanned 120 minutes after extra time.

Cammy Devlin was controversially sent off for a second booking and Oday Dabbagh pounced to send Aberdeen into a final where they will meet Celtic or St Johnstone. Hearts’ season will end with bottom six fixtures in the Premiership and chances of European football next term are over.

Here are how 11 pundits saw the game unfold between Hearts and Aberdeen.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice