"You look at what he done with Aberdeen, and they were a club that were struggling as well. Hearts have had a disappointing season. It's no disrespect to Kilmarnock, I have a great association with them, a fantastic club for me. But you are kind of getting to a stage now where Derek is ready to go back to that stage, a big club. You look at Aberdeen, you look at Hibs, you look at Hearts, you want your big next three clubs. For me, Hearts are the third biggest in the country, you want them up there challenging and causing problems to Rangers and Celtic. The job Derek did at Aberdeen deserves to be back at that level. People forget, and it is easy because of what Derek has achieved in the past, what he has done at Kilmarnock is unbelievable as well. I think he deserves another crack at a big club to see if he can cause problems to our big two."placeholder image
"You look at what he done with Aberdeen, and they were a club that were struggling as well. Hearts have had a disappointing season. It's no disrespect to Kilmarnock, I have a great association with them, a fantastic club for me. But you are kind of getting to a stage now where Derek is ready to go back to that stage, a big club. You look at Aberdeen, you look at Hibs, you look at Hearts, you want your big next three clubs. For me, Hearts are the third biggest in the country, you want them up there challenging and causing problems to Rangers and Celtic. The job Derek did at Aberdeen deserves to be back at that level. People forget, and it is easy because of what Derek has achieved in the past, what he has done at Kilmarnock is unbelievable as well. I think he deserves another crack at a big club to see if he can cause problems to our big two." | Getty Images

13 pundits react on Derek McInnes to Hearts as manager myth busted and one thing guaranteed with boss

Here’s how 13 pundits have reacted to Derek McInnes, who is set to be coming into Hearts as the club’s new manager.

Hearts have found their new manager as Derek McInnes gets set to take office at Tynecastle.

A no brainer in the eyes of some fans and pundits, the Gorgie side have agreed terms with current club Kilmarnock and now some of the finer details are being ironed out before he officially is named Jambos boss. Ironically, his last game in the Killie dugout will be against Hearts this weekend after stating his desire to see out the final week of the season in Ayrshire.

Then attentions will turn to Hearts where a busy summer is ahead after a disappointing 24/25 campaign. Here is what 13 pundits around Scottish football have said about McInnes coming into Hearts.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice