Hearts' different transfer option: JJ Williams' playing style, likely fee, key attributes, who he compares to

American striker is in talks about a move to Tynecastle

The name sounds more like an NBA player than a footballer. Hearts fans probably Googled their fingers numb after reading of the club’s transfer bid for Rhode Island striker JJ Williams in Sunday night’s Edinburgh News exclusive. A 6ft 4in forward playing in the United States second division? Not quite what some expected, but this is Jamestown Analytics at work. Unearthing unknowns is a speciality. After all, nobody knew of Claudio Braga or Alexandros Kyziridis before they arrived in Gorgie last summer.

Williams’ Rhode Island contract expires at the end of November and he is likely to cost Hearts around £100,000. Tynecastle supporters are wondering what they might get for that princely sum. In short, a 28-year-old unit keen for the chance to sample football in Europe. Most of his career has been spent in America’s lower divisions, save for brief spells with MLS clubs Columbus Crew and Atlanta United.

Williams is wanted because he offers different attributes to what Hearts currently have in attack. He is mobile, aggressive and enjoys a bit of hustle and bustle. What he may lack technically he makes up for in physicality. With 11 goals and five assists from 23 appearances with Rhode Island so far this year, he knows where the net is. There is a penchant for a one-touch finish - headers from corners, instinctive shots from crosses - and he thrives on deliveries from out wide.

He is physically strong, aerially dominant, capable of holding the ball, willing to press and defend from the front, but mobile enough to run channels and help create openings for team-mates. The other strikers in Hearts’ squad don’t offer all of those qualities. Braga is likely to be sold before the transfer window closes and Amadou Ba-Sy has been criticised by manager Wouter Vrancken for lacking energy and zest. James Wilson was excellent against Inverness on Sunday but is still a slender teenager learning the game. Landry Kabore is inconsistent at best and might need a move to play more regularly, while Elton Kabangu has been told to find a new club.

The opportunity in Edinburgh is the chance of a lifetime for Williams after 11 different US clubs. “I was looking for somewhere that’s going to make me better at the end of the day. I’m somebody that wants to continue to grow and get better and evolve my game, change my game,” he said after joining Tampa Bay Rowdies in 2023. He enjoyed the best season of his career there with 12 goals and nine assists before leaving later that year just as former Hearts coach Robbie Neilson took charge of the Rowdies.

The man taking him from Florida to Pawtucket was Rhode Island head coach Khano Smith. He was previously assistant at Birmingham Legion, where Williams enjoyed multiple loans and scored a stoppage-time winner against North Carolina in the 2019 USL Championship play-offs. “I've known JJ for a long time, and that was initially why I brought him here,” said Smith. “I know what he brought and I think, for the majority of the time that he’s been in this league, he hasn’t really been afforded the opportunity to play as an out-and-out No.9 for a prolonged period.

“That was always the plan when I brought him here. Obviously, he started the year with the injuries, so that set him back a little bit, but he’s playing well for us at the right time. JJ has showcased throughout his time in the USL Championship that he is capable of scoring goals in key moments, making him a valuable addition to our growing roster. JJ is a goal threat whenever he is on the pitch.”

So Williams’ rise to prominence in the last couple of years - and doubtless his increased rating on JTA’s scouting software - is largely down to a sustained run in his best position. He does not focus only on penalty-area contributions, however. Of his 613 touches for Rhode Island this year, only 87 were in the opposition box, which shows a willingness to work outside the danger zone and get involved in build-up play.

Hearts fans can expect a player similar in style to the likes of Welsh internationalist Kieffer Moore, Stoke City’s Sam Gallagher or Bristol Rovers forward Ellis Harrison. There is also a hint of former Tynecastle loanee Ellis Simms in him. For an American reference, Williams could be considered a lower-level version of the former USA international striker Jozy Altidore.

He scored the first hat-trick in Rhode Island’s short history - the club only began playing competitively two years ago - against Miami FC in October 2024 following a calf injury. “It’s something that I told myself I wanted to do right when I signed here,” he said. “I was hoping it was going to come a lot earlier in the year. Whenever you have to miss the first 10 [games], this is one of those that keeps you coming back for more.”

He will soon be coming for more in Scotland as Hearts work to finalise this transfer deal and secure a UK work permit. Jerome Williams Junior will certainly bring a different dimension to the Tynecastle attack.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice