Hearts fans right to feel angry despite positive transfer moves
Gary Mackay says it’s okay for Jambos not to feel okay
There are mixed and delicate feelings in and around Tynecastle Park nearly three weeks since the season ended. Hearts are progressing with multiple pieces of transfer business, determined to assemble a squad ready for next month’s Champions League qualifying phase. Yet there is still dismay and disillusion following the conclusion to the 2025/26 campaign. Emotions remain raw despite some positive and encouraging recruitment work.
Winger Josh McPake and defender MJ Kamson-Kamara are signed, midfielder Tom Renaud is all agreed and winger Calvin Miller should put pen to paper after a medical. Forward Amadou Ba-Sy may follow soon after, and Hearts are still in talks about a possible deal for Malachi Fagan-Walcott. Club officials know the clock is ticking towards that first European tie on 21 or 22 July. Some supporters feel excited, others still angry following last season’s ending. Many are a mixture of both.
Losing the league at Celtic Park in the dying minutes of the season was crushing for everyone concerned with Hearts. Compounding the misery were refereeing decisions which went against them over the previous week: Alexandros Kyziridis was refused a penalty against Motherwell at Fir Park, Celtic were awarded a controversial one days later almost on the same spot on the same pitch against the same opponents.
Subsequent admissions from the Scottish Football Association that a Key Match Incidents panel deemed both decisions incorrect merely rubbed salt into Jambo wounds. Then came the devastating final minutes at Celtic Park. A 1-1 scoreline which would have seen Hearts crowned champions became a 3-1 defeat to secure the title for Celtic. Then came that pitch invasion amid fears for player safety. Then Lawrence Shankland left for free to join Rangers.
It will take some time to recover from that series of seemingly-relentless blows. For Hearts fans, it felt like all of their worst nightmares inside a couple of weeks. To their credit, Tynecastle management are not standing still to wallow in self-pity. They realise the new season will be upon them soon enough and are being proactive in the transfer market. There is a determination to ensure 2025/26 was not a one-off. ‘Just the beginning’ is a favourite phrase as Hearts aim to mount another sustained Premiership challenge.
New signings are designed to strengthen Derek McInnes’ first-team squad and supporters will certainly welcome the good news. In the meantime, if there is a difficulty shrugging off what happened last month, it is understandable. “I think it’s really important, from a Hearts supporter’s perspective, to say how we feel. It’s okay not to be okay,” says Gary Mackay, the club’s record appearance holder. He is adamant more should be done to deal with Celtic fans’ behaviour and the officiating which left Hearts reeling.
“It’s okay to be disappointed, disillusioned and hurt. There are loads of reasons for that. You have to wonder if anything else is going to come from what happened towards the end of the season, or is it now yesterday’s news? It would be nice to have that knowledge as a group of fans.
“People go on about us being paranoid and biased but, as a supporter group, when you go through what we’ve been through, I’m not sure paranoia or bias is a thing. When you’ve been through Save Our Hearts, the club close to going out of business, then Foundation of Hearts stepping in, this is all in the last 20 or 25 years. There has been a lot of learning as a football club.
“You’re learning as a football club but then there is a lack of learning at our top football organisations regarding pitch invasions and everything else. It beggars belief that the football authorities have witnessed these pitch invasions at different times - because they aren’t just one-offs - yet the first people to be sanctioned for anything are Falkirk Football Club for some pyro.
“I get that pyro is very dangerous and we have to be very careful, so I’m not condoning that. It just seems absurd to me that there is this lack of responsibility over officials’ decisions. Again, I’d never condone a referee’s personal details being shared in the public domain. Then Ian Maxwell said he spent a night dealing with police to protect a referee. You can’t condone that for one second, but sometimes people get carried away in life and in football. Sometimes they get carried away because they feel things have been dealt with in an unjust manner.”
The Hearts board have issued statements conveying the club’s stance on how they and their players were treated at Celtic Park. There is now a disciplinary investigation taking place into events during and after the Celtic-Hearts match. The Scottish Professional Football League are looking at possible sanctions over pitch invasions and other misdemeanours.
“The Hearts board will know how to deal with it better than me because me emotion for the club comes across differently,” says Mackay. “I think it’s important to make the point that it’s okay not to be okay with this. That’s how we feel as supporters. Has anybody asked Derek McInnes how he feels? He came to Hearts, came close to winning the league for the first time in 66 years and then these things go against us.
“Ben Kensell, the Hibs chief executive, questioned the standard of refereeing at Celtic Park three years ago. His club were involved and the referee involved [Steven McLean] was the one Ben Kensell spoke to. He questioned some of his decisions. Has it had any impact? That same official is still making decisions affecting clubs in the east of Scotland.”
Acknowledgement from a KMI panel that decisions which damaged Hearts’ title bid were wrong are no help in the cold light of day. “It’s too little too late,” says Mackay. “We are told VAR isn’t going away. A referee goes to a monitor, he makes a decision in his mind that you hope is the correct one, but three days later the KMI panel say it’s wrong. That’s too little too late.
“When people like Gary Lineker and Tim Sherwood - who played at a far higher level than myself, Ian Maxwell or any Scottish referee - are saying some of these decisions are among the worst they have seen in their lifetime, we have a problem.”
