'You can't jump the pyramid.' Celtic and Rangers colts must start at bottom of Scottish football, says Bonnyrigg Rose boss Robbie Horn

Lowland and Highland teams more deserving of SPFL places
Bonnyrigg Rose manager Robbie Horn feels his team deserve a shot at the SPFL before Celtic and Rangers colt teams.Bonnyrigg Rose manager Robbie Horn feels his team deserve a shot at the SPFL before Celtic and Rangers colt teams.
Bonnyrigg Rose manager Robbie Horn feels his team deserve a shot at the SPFL before Celtic and Rangers colt teams.

Bonnyrigg Rose manager Robbie Horn insists his club deserve a place in the Scottish Professional Football League more than Celtic and Rangers colt teams.

Whilst not opposing the idea of B sides to develop young players, Horn stressed that they must start at the bottom of the pyramid and not jump the queue into League Two.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

That would mean applying to join the East of Scotland, West of Scotland or South of Scotland leagues, and working their way up from there.

Rangers have circulated a reconstruction plan detailing a 14-14-18 model which would increase the Scottish Professional Football League from 42 teams to 46.

Celtic are prepared to back their rivals’ idea as it would permit both Glasgow clubs to enter under-21 sides in an 18-club bottom tier, with Lowland and Highland League winners Kelty Hearts and Brora Rangers also joining.

Celtic and Rangers colts would pay a yearly membership fee for four years, starting at £125,000 and reducing by £25,000 each season. They would also pay for 200 away tickets for each match and to stream matches, with all proceeds going to third-tier clubs.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Hearts are also behind the plan and other teams would have the option to enter colts in future, but Horn insisted the pyramid structure should not be disregarded to let the biggest clubs in the country do what they want.

If four new clubs are to be added to the SPFL, as per the Rangers document, he believes it should be Kelty and Brora plus the runners-up in the Lowland and Highland leagues when football was shut down – Bonnyrigg Rose and either Inverurie Locos or Fraserburgh.

"Ideally that's what I would like. In an ideal world, it would be us and either Inverurie or Fraserburgh along with Kelty and Brora stepping into the SPFL if you are increasing it to 46 teams,” Horn told the Evening News.

“My honest feeling is that won't happen. It would be right to include these teams but I just can't see league reconstruction happening.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"In theory this is a great idea because it's bringing money to the lower league teams, but clubs trying to work their way up the pyramid would be watching these colt teams come straight in above them. That's the frustration because they would be jumping the pyramid.

"This idea has been talked about for a few years now. If colt teams had started at the bottom of the pyramid when it was first mentioned, they would probably be in League Two by now. I don't have a problem with them starting at the lowest point and working their way up.

"It would be great for them to bring their money to non-league teams at the bottom of the pyramid. Starting in League Two is an issue for everybody. It would cause a lot of controversy, although I get what they are trying to do.

“If they are going to do it, they need to start at the bottom like everybody else. That would be the East of Scotland League or the West of Scotland League.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“You couldn't even have them in the Lowland League. They would need to work their way up from the bottom. That's the way the pyramid system works.

"There is something not quite right about jumping straight into League Two and missing out the rest of the pyramid. I think that's where the problem would lie for a lot of people.”

Hearts owner Ann Budge circulated her own restructuring plan for three leagues of 14 but is willing to back Rangers’ suggestion along with Celtic.

Others in Scotland have placed colt sides in the East of Scotland league in recent years because they were not allowed a springboard into the SPFL. Horn would regard anything else as a “slap in the face” for teams like Bonnyrigg.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"Hibs and Berwick Rangers have both had teams in the East of Scotland and planned to work their way up,” recalled Horn. “Other countries do it, if you look at the Barcelona and Real Madrid B teams in Spain.

"It's a good thing for the development of young players. They would be playing against men who are seasoned pros and that would help them progress. It would make them a bit more battle-hardened. Sometimes when you go to watch youth football it can seem a bit false.

"Our season has finished but we still felt we had an opportunity to win the league and get into the play-offs for a League Two place. It's hard enough with all the talk regarding Kelty and Brora still having an outside chance to be part of league reconstruction. That could have been us.

"We have accepted it now, we wish them all the best and we move on. We do think it's right for the pyramid that Lowland and Highland clubs get a chance to be part of the SPFL. We are behind it in that respect but, at the same time, it's a sore one for us because we felt we had a chance of the title.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"For something else to come along, like colt teams being pushed into League Two ahead of us, that would be another wee slap in the face. A lot of clubs at this level are investing quite heavily in their teams for next season with a view to promotion.

"East Kilbride have a new management team with Stevie Aitken and Ian Durrant, and they're identifying players to come in. These clubs are spending lots of money with the ambition to get into the SPFL. I just think the whole thing has to open up a bit more.”

As it stands, the team finishing bottom of League Two enters a play-off with the Highland League or Lowland League winners for the right to play in the SPFL the following season.

"The bottom team in League Two should be automatically relegated and the place above it should go into a play-off,” stated Horn.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“The Rangers proposal says the bottom tier would become an 18-team league – but the bottom team is still only going into a play-off. It's actually ridiculous.

"The middle tier would have two relegation spots for a 14-team division, but the bottom would only have one play-off place for the bottom team and that's an 18-team division? It needs looked at but there are some reasonable ideas within it.”

A message from the Editor: Thank you for reading this story on our website. While I have your attention, I also have an important request to make of you. In order for us to continue to provide high quality and trusted local news on this free-to-read site, I am asking you to also please purchase a copy of our newspaper. Our journalists are highly-trained and our content is independently regulated by IPSO to some of the most rigorous standards in the world. But being your eyes and ears comes at a price. So we need your support more than ever to buy our newspapers during this crisis. With the coronavirus lockdown having a major impact on many of our local valued advertisers - and consequently the advertising that we receive - we are more reliant than ever on you helping us to provide you with news and information by buying a copy of our newspaper. Thank you. Joy Yates, Editorial Director.