Handball inconsistency and missed penalty have hurt Hibs against Rangers - will luck even out at Ibrox?

David Gray knows ‘fine margins’ always make the difference in this fixture

An infuriatingly inconsistent handball decision at Ibrox. And a dramatic late penalty save at Easter Road. To say that Hibs haven’t enjoyed much luck in their two meetings with Rangers this season would be something of an understatement.

Not one to rake over the embers of what might have been, David Gray believes the nature of his team’s performances in those fixtures – a 2-0 Premier Sports Cup loss in Glasgow and a 1-0 league defeat on home soil – proves how close Hibs are to toppling Rangers. Again.

Winners at Ibrox as recently as April, when they ran out 2-0 victors with something to spare, Hibs will obviously need to play well if they’re to emulate that achievement tomorrow night. And they’ll need just a breath or two of good fortune from the footballing gods. Something that has eluded them for much of the current campaign.

Back in September, for instance, Martin Boyle appeared to have given Hibs a 1-0 lead over Russell Martin’s struggling home side in the Premier Sports Cup quarter-final. But VAR ruled that, because the ball had struck Boyle on the left arm as he was running into beat Butland, the goal should be disallowed.

When is a handball not a handball? (Clue: This one WASN’T penalised)

Given the maddening lack of consistency surrounding handball, Gray did well not to blow his top after the game, merely pointing out that opposing teams had NOT been punished for similar offences against Hibs. Adamant that the right decision had been reached, even if the contact by Boyle was “completely accidental”, the gaffer said: “I'm only frustrated because of inconsistency. My biggest issue is it’s the same as what happened with us with penalty decisions in games. So it's probably just the inconsistency which is the word that's been frustratingly used a lot of late.”

In fairness, after being denied that goal, Hibs more than contributed to their own downfall by losing two goals just before half-time. It wasn’t a vintage performance by either side.

When they met at Easter Road just a month later, Hibs were again guilty of self-inflicted wounds, gifting Rangers – now under the new management of Danny Rohl - a very soft goal. Jack Butland saving Jamie McGrath’s penalty in the dying moments capped a rough night for the hosts, but it genuinely felt like the game was there for the taking.

Easter Road side have shown quality v Rangers

Reflecting on that narrow loss this week, Gray – who knows his team can overtake Rangers with a victory tomorrow – told The Evening News: “On reflection, it shows that it’s always fine margins for us. It has been for a wee while.

“And at a certain time we obviously missed a penalty on the night, lost a really poor goal on the night that night as well. So, I think, as we’ve demonstrated already, we're a really good side when we play at that level.

“I think you need to play well to win at Ibrox. That's an obvious answer. You need to play to a very high level.

“You need to take chances when they come. At times, there will be periods in the game where Rangers will have possession of the ball and make you suffer a little bit, so you have to be ready for that.

“You also need to believe going along that you can go and do it, and I think that's the biggest plus you can have. You need to be brave. You need to be brave with and without the ball, and I think that's probably the key going along there.

“You're heavily outnumbered in terms of fans and the atmosphere and being able to play on that, but the players should relish the opportunity to go and do that. It's a brilliant place to go and play, a real old-fashioned stadium, a traditional stadium. The atmosphere can be electric, so it's a great opportunity for the players to go and impress.”

Hibs have the talent to get a result tomorrow. As for the fortune, fine margins and 50-50 decisions that can make all the difference, well, they’ll entitled to feel that it’s about time the universe balanced the books with a little nudge in the direction of the visitors.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice