Handball guessing game a constant frustration for Scottish football as Hibs switch focus to Celtic test

David Gray’s men need to bounce back from collective failure of 2-0 away loss to Motherwell

There’s a price to be paid for admission to the upper echelons of the Scottish Premiership. And it’s not a one-off fee. As Hibs are discovering.

Oh sure, you can trade a gutsy performance for a day ticket. Invest a little more to have a mini-break in among the elite.

But actually maintaining a position inside, for example, the top three? That requires something more substantial.

To be blunt, anyone wanting to hang around the fringes of the SPFL title race must prove that they belong. Every single day. They can enjoy the seat in first class. But must present their ticket for inspection with maddening regularity.

As David Gray prepares his team to take on reigning champions Celtic at Easter Road this weekend, he’ll certainly be seeking an upgrade on the performance at Fir Park last night. The way Hibs crumbled in the opening 20 minutes or so is a major concern for a manager who consistently credits his players with mental fortitude and solid organisational skills.

So what did we learn from a 2-0 defeat punctuated by yet more VAR interventions and philosophical discussions about handball intentions? And what improvements do Hibs need to effect if they’re to bounce back with a win over Celtic on Sunday?

Handball? It’s now a guessing game

When a stadium announcer informs the paying customers that there is a VAR check for a possible offence, what goes through your mind, as a fan? Probably the same thing that most coaches and managers experience – concern mixed with confusion.

Everyone knows that the handball law remains a mess, providing so much room for interpretation and judgement calls that virtually identical ‘offences’ can produce two different decisions. Both of which can be justified by citing support from the woolly guidelines.

St Mirren man got away with one at Easter Road earlier in the season

Grant Hanley is closing an opponent down and shaping his body to show him towards the byeline when the shot – struck from very close range - hits his left hand. Like so many penalties awarded this year, it falls into the category marked: Probably shouldn’t be a penalty … but is, under the current rules.

That’s fine, if the same interpretation is applied across the board. Without that consistency, all you’re doing is adding another element of uncertainty to a game inherently infused with natural chaos.

A collective failure

When Gray described his team’s opening 25 minutes as “really poor”, he wasn’t exaggerating for effect, the gaffer saying: “That wasn’t down to one individual; it was a collective performance from us, which is something I’ve not seen for a while. And we certainly need to look at whay that happened.

“I think we probably got what we deserved for our first 20-25 minutes of the game. Which is nothing. We were very unlike us. Started the game slowly, really poor in possession. A lot of unforced errors, a lot of misplaced passes.

“And then everything that could go against us did in that period as well. Found ourselves going 2-0 down, down to 10 men.”

Scotland hero Hanley misses Celtic

There’s no real complaint about the red card shown to Hanley for denying an opponent a goal scoring opportunity. As soon as VAR showed that Tawanda Maswanhise was onside, the big man was busted.

Warren O’Hora, who came on in a reshaped back four last night, will step back into the right side of a back three on Sunday, almost certainly. That allows Rocky Bushiri return to the position he had made his own before Hanley’s arrival – smack dab in the middle of the defensive line, setting the offside and organising the troops.

Asked if his team could bounce back against the reigning champions on Sunday, Gray said simply: “Yes, absolutely. There's nothing else for it.

“I think one thing we won't do is just move on quickly. We'll reflect on why we started the way we did and look at that. We don't just sweep these things under the carpet.

“We need to make sure we're better for it. We've got enough time to get the players recovered and ready for an opportunity to try and put this result and performance right.”

Some glimmer of hope?

Martin Boyle’s goal-bound effort being cleared off the line late in the first half was more or less the final incident of note in a game that fell off dramatically after the break. Almost as if both teams were already looking towards their weekend fixtures, bringing on substitutes and playing within themselves.

Still, Gray takes some comfort from the fact that his team didn’t end up on the wrong end of a thumping when they went down to ten men, declaring: “I think they did show character. They did show effort. They didn't just roll over. I think that's clear.

“Especially because of the way we quickly found ourselves 2-0 down, down to 10 men. The way Motherwell were playing on the front.

“Would it have been easy to feel sorry for yourself? I don't think they did. I don't think we carried enough of a threat, though.

“But it would have been easy to just roll over and feel sorry for ourselves. I don't think they've done that. So I can't fault the players for effort, for going right to the very end. But we certainly didn't deserve to get back into the game.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice