Exclusive:Hibs swap familiarity for the unknown as former boss weighs in on Reedijk’s appointment and Gray’s next move
Alan Stubbs explains why Dutchman’s first weeks at Easter Road could prove crucial and why sacked boss should resist the urge to rush back into management
For a club accustomed to viewing its next managerial appointment through the prism of expectation, Hibs’ decision to entrust Marink Reedijk with the head coach role represents something of a departure from the norm.
The Dutchman checks in at Easter Road with an intriguing CV rather than the established profile some supporters might have expected, having built his reputation in youth development before enjoying success in Belgium.
One man who knows better than most the demands of the job is former Hibs boss Alan Stubbs, who believes the appointment is fascinating precisely because it represents something of an unknown.


“I am intrigued, actually,” Stubbs told the Edinburgh Evening News in cooperation with Gambler Media. “It's going to prove to be either a bold choice or one of those decisions where you wonder how we came to it. I certainly hope it's a successful appointment.”
Stubbs can understand the thinking behind the club’s decision. Reedijk’s track record in developing young players makes for impressive reading, and that experience is likely to be central to how Hibs want to play.
“He's got a very strong background in youth football, bringing young players through. I think he's been at Ajax, and he's had a solid upbringing through youth football and into the under-21s. When you look at his CV, you can see why Hibs have gone for this type of manager. But it's a tough role.”
Stubbs: ‘Hibs are set up for success’ under new boss
The timing of Reedijk’s arrival makes the challenge tougher still. Hibs have appointed the 34-year-old with the season already in full swing, limiting his ability to reshape the squad until the January transfer window opens. More significantly, the club enters a new era against the backdrop of impressive progress made by city rivals Hearts.
“The problem for Hibs, especially after last season, is that their neighbours did very well, and that heightens the pressure on the manager and the players. They have to deal with it. It's a brilliant club and I loved my time there. It's set up for success. The infrastructure and training grounds are first class, the stadium is excellent and the budget is very healthy.
“The recruitment is what they need to get right. I wish him all the best and hope he's a real success. It's an interesting appointment.”
The immediate task facing Reedijk, therefore, is not simply to implement a different tactical philosophy but to persuade an existing group of players to embrace it.
Stubbs experienced something similar when he replaced Terry Butcher in the Easter Road hotseat and knows that changing a squad’s habits can be considerably more complicated than changing a formation on a tactics board.
“The difficult thing is that the manager has come in after the season has started and the window has closed. He has to deal with this group of players from now until January and try to get them as competitive as possible.
“As with any turnaround, there will be players the manager really likes and players who aren't in his thinking, and he has to make up his mind very quickly. Then the problem is moving on players who could still be on two-year contracts. A lot goes on.


“I'd have thought this international break is a good one for the nucleus of the squad. It gives him three weeks to get his ideas across. He'll have a different style of play to David.”
The international break and warm-weather camp in La Manga offer Reedijk invaluable time on the training pitch with his players; an opportunity to establish his principles, expectations and “non-negotiables”, while also convincing some that they have a future under his leadership.
That process is as much psychological as tactical, Stubbs reckons. “It’s a chance for the players to have some one-to-one time with him while he explains what he expects, how he wants to play and where he sees them. He has to get them to buy into his methods and his outlook on football.”
Gray urged to avoid rushing back into management
That need for buy-in also provides important context following David Gray’s dismissal. Gray was Stubbs’ first signing when he took charge of Hibs, making his departure all the more difficult for his former manager to stomach.
Stubbs reckons Gray would benefit from taking time to reflect rather than rushing back into management — a mistake he made himself.
“He'll learn from it. His first job was a big one, and I wish him all the very best,” Stubbs said. “He'll probably need time to reflect on why the decision was made and what he could have done better. It's always a reflective and sombre time for a manager, because you tend to blame yourself.
“Ultimately, you're the one responsible for being in charge. But it's not always down to one individual. There could have been things behind the scenes that we may never learn about. He might have missed out on two or three recruitment targets that could have made the difference to this squad.


“Last season, David went through a sticky period and then a really impressive unbeaten run. Before that run started, some Hibs fans were calling for him to leave. So he's shown he can turn it around. However, in the modern day you're only one game away from the sack, or one game away from a crisis. That's how short-term it's become.
“He has a very young family, and it'll be nice for him to spend time with them. Knowing David, he'll dust himself down - he's resilient, very level-headed, and has a strong mind to overcome this. What happens next will be down to how he feels.
“It's really important not to jump in. That's one of the things I did: I jumped back in too quickly, rather than thinking about whether it was right. I'll probably give David a call once the dust settles and have a chat. One thing I'll say to him is don't rush into another role unless you're 100% sure it's the right one.”