Marvin Bartley breathes VAR sigh of relief amid Hibs incident as Livingston boss questions 'top level' referee

Hibs were awarded a penalty in the dying minutes of the game of their SPFL Premiership clash with Livi that was swiftly overturned.

Livingston boss, Marvin Bartley has questioned the standard of refereeing in the Scottish top flight after an incident that took place against Hibs at Easter Road.

The former Hibee returned to the Leith for the first time since he was given the permanent managerial role at Livi and escaped with a point, despite the hosts having countless chances in their goalless draw. Jamie McGrath came closest for Hibs as he hit the woodwork twice either side of half time, in what was a frustrating afternoon for David Gray’s men against the league’s bottom side.

Hibs thought they had a golden opportunity to win it at the death when referee Lloyd Wilson pointed to the spot after substitute Martin Boyle went down in the box under the challenge of Mohamed Sylla. However, VAR Greg Aitken told the Wilson to go to the monitor to rethink his decision, as the Lions defender got a touch on the ball first.

Bartley on VAR incident vs Hibs

While the Livingston boss was thankful that the officials came to that decision in the end, he also criticised the performance of the on-field official. He claimed that if his blunder had been made in a division which didn’t have access to VAR, it could’ve proved costly.

Bartley said: “I was rubbing my eyes because that decision's up there. The problem for me is that one, it's given so quickly after clearly he wins the ball and the other thing is if you're not in the top flight and you don't have half, that's going down as a penalty kick right at the end of the game.

“That would cost the team a hard-earned point. So, yes, we're delighted that we do have VAR up here but I think that's something that Willie Collum needs to look at because I didn't think the performance overall from Lloyd today was up to the top level.”

Livi undergoing mini-revival

Livingston sit nine points behind 11th placed Kilmarnock at the wrong end of the Scottish Premiership table and haven’t won a game since August. However, under the stewardship of Bartley they’ve now drawn their last four in a row, including other tough fixtures against Rangers at home and Dundee away. While the Livi boss would like to turn draws into wins, he remains pleased with progress his players have made since his appointment.

He continued: “I thought the players were absolutely brilliant (against Hibs). They gave me absolutely everything. We ask for that every single day, every game and we saw that today. Even the subs that came on gave us new energy and they had to be disciplined and they were that. I wouldn't mind a win, by the way. We just keep drawing games and I getting abuse from people when I go to the gym.

“It would be even worse tomorrow actually because I go to the gym in Edinburgh. So, yes, I wouldn't mind a win, would I? But listen, it's our second clean sheet of the season. We're heading in the right direction. Obviously, we're making ourselves more difficult to beat but like you said, that elusive win, hopefully it will come. Everyone keeps telling me it's definitely going to come but we're running out of games.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice