Stand-in Smith keeps Murrayfield on course in Dispatch Trophy
Golf Correspondent Martin Dempster rounds up the third-round action at the Braids
It was “one and done” for Allan Smith as Murrayfield, last year’s beaten finalists, stayed on course to go one better in the 126th Edinburgh Evening News Dispatch Trophy at the Braids.
Smith, a 46-year-old who plays off 2.7, replaced Bobby Gibson from the team that won twice on Saturday for a last-16 clash in the Edinburgh Leisure-run tournament.
Rising to the challenge, he teamed up with Cameron White to finish five up in the top match against the Armstrong brothers - Gary and Steven.


With Stuart Thurlow and Harrison Shaw getting off to a “hot start” in the match behind and just keeping their noses in front against Gregor Jackson and Blair Henry, Murrayfield safely progressed to the quarter-finals.
“That’s one and done for me,” declared Smith, who is set to make way for Gibson’s return on Thursday night, “but I will be happy to share the victory if the guys can go all the way.”
White and Thurlow were in the team that lost to Hailes in last year’s trophy decider, but Archie Wyatt and Harry Hawthorne are unavailable for this edition, which is once again being sponsored by Braid Hills Golf Centre. Wyatt is currently playing in the NCAA Men’s Regional Finals in Florida while Hawthorne has St Andrews University commitments.
Shaw, the current Murrayfield junior champion, is making his Dispatch Trophy debut and the 18-year-old admitted with a smile: “It is class”.
Dalmahoy are next up for Murrayfield despite both Kilspindie pairings making birdie-2s at the 17th as they battled hard to overcome a six-hole deficit at the turn.
It’s been a dream debut for 15-year-old Luke Wu, but, unfortunately, he’ll be up the Pentlands on a Duke of Edinburgh Award expedition when the next round is taking place.
“Hopefully the team can go all the way without me - that would be great,” he said of Richard Fyvie, Michael Jackson and George Johnston and AN Other being left to get on with matters.
Edinburgh Western beat Thistle 1870 in an all-Braids clash to set up a last-eight meeting with Riccarton A.


“Our opponents on Saturday asked us when we last won the event and I said ‘22,” revealed Danny Cameron after keeping the event’s self-proclaimed Dad’s Army marching on along with Andrew Rennie, Keith McFarlane and David Wilson.
“He replied to that by saying ‘2022 wasn’t that long ago’ - but I then had to point out that it was 1922!”
Helped by their opponents losing balls in both matches at the 16th in the low sun, Riccarton A beat Harrison B, conquerors of five-time winners Silverknowes on Saturday.
“We’re buzzing to be through to Thursday,” declared debutant Fergus Lockhart, with Mark Riddell, Owen Brady and Jake Edgcombe all having played before in the historic tournament.
Carrickvale, the event’s dominant force when lifting the trophy five times, have glory in their sights again after beating a Swanston side that included 14-year-old Harry Mody.
“He’s a very, very good golfer,” observed Gregor Maiden, who is wearing Carrickvale colours for this edition with Ross Colquhoun, Paul Cunningham and Allyn Dick.
Turnhouse team BBT are Carrickvale’s last-eight opponents while the remaining tie on Thursday sees Heriot’s FP, conquerors of defending champions Hailes, take on Stewart’s Melville FP.
RESULTS
Third round
Murrayfield (Cameron Whyte and Alan Smith 5; Stuart Thurlow and Harrison Shaw 1); Turnhouse (Steven Armstrong and Eddie Jackson 0; Keith Watt and Blair Henry 0).
Murrayfield won 6&4
Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club (Luke Wu and Richard Fyvie 1; Michael Jackson and George Johnston 2); Kilspindie (Gareth Evans and Carter Jerome 0; Rob Green and Derek Thomson 0).
Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club won 3&1
Edinburgh Western (Andrew Rennie and Keith MacFarlane 5; David Wilson and Danny Cameron 3); Thistle 1870 (Ross Turner and Niall Moffat 0; Luke Robinson and Tom Olley 0).
Edinburgh Western won 8&6
Harrison B (Scott Knowles and Freddie Stevenson 0; Robbie Sim and Mark Anderson 0); Riccarton A (Mark Riddell and Owen Brady 1; Jake Edgcombe and Fergus Lockhart 3).
Riccarton A won 4&3
Swanston (Harry Mody and Andrew Letton 0; Nick Harrison and Mark Evans 1); Carrickvale (Gregor Maiden and Ross Colquhoun 7; Paul Cunningham and Allyn Dick 0).
Carrickvale won 6&5
Edinburgh Leisure (Matthew Harper and Cameron Ledingham 3; Scott Higgins and Gary Reilly 0); BBT (Michael Watt and Jack McVey 0; Kyle Wilson and Calum Robinson 8).
BBT won 5&4
Stewart’s Melville FP (Scott Simpson and Drew McIntosh 6; Nick Barr and Derek Miller 0); Heriot’s Quad (Innes Christie and Euan Gordon 0; John Liddel and Stewart Heggie 0).
Stewart’s Melville FP won 6&5
Hailes (Scott Finlayson and Fraser Sutherland 0; Paul Page and Danny Crolla 0); Heriot’s FP (Ben Alexander and Elliot Innes 4; Steven Sinclair and Scott Dickson 3).
Heriot’s FP won 7&5
