Community group considering legal action against plans to ‘destroy’ Edinburgh ‘haven of biodiversity’

More than 140 species of plants and animals have been counted around Western Harbour’s ponds

A community group is ready to take legal action to protect “a haven of biodiversity” from plans to build hundreds of homes.

Friends of Western Harbour Ponds have raised enough money to hire an advocate to investigate whether there are reasonable grounds for a Judicial Review into approved plans to build 155 apartments on the brownfield land.

The waterfront plot was awarded planning permission in March subject to the completion of legal conditions by developer FM Property such as a land survey and fully detailed landscape plan.

Save Western Harbour Ponds have been campaigning against the development since they were pictured here in 2023placeholder image
Save Western Harbour Ponds have been campaigning against the development since they were pictured here in 2023

It took the group just four days to raise the £1,620 needed to make the first step towards challenging the planning application, which has received 512 objections.

The group’s chair Gareth Overton said: “There’s something very special going on there. There’s birds, flowers, wildlife and it’s a beautiful space to spend your time in.

“I fully acknowledge there is a housing crisis and we need more affordable homes but it’s where you put them and what value they bring. This is just the very last place you should put a few homes in order to try and have any significant impact on your housing crisis.”

The plans were provisionally given the go-ahead in Marchplaceholder image
The plans were provisionally given the go-ahead in March | FM Property

Edinburgh Waterfront is one of four Strategic Development Areas which the council have identified for long-term regeneration and housing-led development.

Redevelopment plans for the Western Harbour breakwater were originally approved in 2004 but much of the land has not been touched since building came to halt following the financial crisis.

Planning permission for 212 homes in the gap between the early 2000s development is expected to start building in 2027 and be completed in 2029, however it is still awaiting assessment from the council.

FM Property, meanwhile, is holding a second pre-application consultation for neighbouring plots at the Heart of Newhaven on Wednesday, November 18, which include Western Harbour’s ponds.

The developer wants to build homes around Western Harbour's pondsplaceholder image
The developer wants to build homes around Western Harbour's ponds | FM Property

The developer plans to construct apartment blocks around the two ponds, which Mr Overton said would turn the “haven of biodiversity” into what is essentially a “water feature”.

His group said more than 140 species of plants and animals have been counted in the “absolutely essential green space”, including swans, sand martins and herons.

They say a tree preservation order was recently ignored by the developer who reportedly had to be told by the council's planning enforcement team that no further unauthorised work can be carried out until they secure planning permission.

FM Property did not respond to a request for comment.

The FM Property plots (left) are joined by plans for a 212 home development (right)placeholder image
The FM Property plots (left) are joined by plans for a 212 home development (right) | Iconic

Friends of Western Harbour Ponds are being assisted by retired legal professional Pamela Bowman, who said she got involved because she has grown to cherish the ponds over the last 17 years living at Western Harbour.

Mr Overton said: “It feels very difficult for people with no funds, no professional expertise and no capacity to fight against the interests of parties who can spend one million quid of a plot of land speculatively.

“The vote in March went five to four against us. We nearly wouldn’t have been having this battle here but we are determined to make sure that the needs of nature are balanced against the need of housing.

“The needs of nature should clearly overwhelmingly win in this case.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice