Deal on handover of Edinburgh's Royal Infirmary to NHS leaves taxpayers with huge bill
Transfer of PFI-built hospital to public ownership due next year
Taxpayers will be left with a huge bill running into tens of millions of pounds when Edinburgh’s Royal Infirmary is transferred to public ownership next year, it is reported.
A deal agreed between NHS Lothian and Consort, the private consortium which built and maintains the hospital, is said to fall short of providing enough money to carry out necessary upgrades at the hospital.


The infirmary at Little France was built under a controversial Public Finance Initiative (PFI) contract dating back to 1998, which meant Consort being paid around £1 billion to build and then maintain the hospital over 25 years before handing it over to the NHS.
The transfer is due next year and, according to a report by the BBC, NHS Lothian and Consort have resolved a four-year dispute about maintenance standards with a deal where Consort will set aside up to £86m for upgrades.
But an NHS Lothian assessment warned the sum was "anticipated to fall well short" of what was needed and fire safety upgrades alone are expected to cost over £90m.
Other improvements required include new lighting, ventilation and electrical systems.
Some of the works are already under way while others will stretch beyond the date of the official handover, the BBC said.
It quoted a report to NHS Lothian’s finance committee in June which said: "Considering all expenditure to date, and items currently identified to be addressed, a deficit of £9.7m is predicted” - not including the cost of further fire preventative measures or unanticipated future works due to system failures.
It also said the deal agreed between NHS Lothian and Consort meant the consortium would keep receiving monthly PFI payments until December, 2027 but is not allowed to pay any dividends to its shareholders or get into further debt.
And it quoted Anne Stafford, professor of accounting and finance, at the University of Manchester, saying the deal was “too little, too late”.
She said: "The documentation suggests that significant infrastructure risks, asset obsolescence and maintenance liabilities had accumulated to the point where major replacement programmes for critical systems - such as ventilation systems and fire safety measures - were only being addressed in the final years before hand back.
"The implication is that a substantial proportion of the costs associated with restoring the estate to an acceptable standard may ultimately fall on the public sector after contract expiry.
"Rather than receiving an asset that has been systematically renewed throughout the concession period, the public sector faces the prospect of inheriting significant residual investment needs, creating additional pressure on public finances and potentially delaying wider service improvements."
NHS Lothian finance director Craig Marriott told the BBC a detailed assessment of the building's condition was carried out in 2022 to ensure contractual obligations would being met ahead of next year's handover.
He said: "This identified shortfalls in fire measures which were reported to the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, Consort and other stakeholders.
"Following extensive negotiations and advice from legal, technical and financial experts a handback agreement was recommended as the best value option. Alternative approaches carried risks, including potential disruption to patient care.
"While the agreed funding may not cover every identified issue, it represents a significant investment in the facility that may not have otherwise been secured."
The BBC said Consort declined to comment.