Heritage body criticised over £42k 'spin doctor' role amid Edinburgh hostel row

Campaigners have said a move to hire a senior communications chief at an under-fire heritage body is a “misreading of the organisation’s problems”

Edinburgh World Heritage (EWH) has been criticised by campaigners after advertising a £42,000-a-year senior communications role amid an ongoing row over its support for a controversial 544-bed hostel in the Capital’s West End.

The role, which would report to EWH director Terry Levinthal, is expected to “ensure a compelling narrative for all organisational activities” and act as a prime contact for media and “rapid reply” management. The closing date for the role was last month.

However, campaigners fighting the proposed hostel on Atholl Crescent said the move represents “a fundamental misreading of the organisation’s problems”. Campaigners have also accused EWH of “not learning from mistakes” and spending public money on reputation management.

Philip Flockhart, the conservation architect leading the Atholl Crescent campaign, said: “They appear to think their problem is one of communications, rather than one of judgment. This is a self-inflicted crisis. In terms of communications EWH do not conform to even the basic professional courtesy of replying to our requests for accountability.

“Why are they spending charitable and public money on PR to defend the poor judgement of their director? The proposed PR salary over a ten-year period would pay for an entire year of discretionary grants which EWH award annually to heritage projects in the city.”

The development, proposed by Atholl Crescent Propco Ltd, controversially won the support of EWH. Edinburgh World Heritage (EWH) said the proposed use was "acceptable" and added: "We support the heritage-led approach taken, noting the high degree of reversibility of the scheme.”

Architect Philip Flockhart on Atholl Crescent. He has questioned EWH’s hiring of a ‘spin doctor’placeholder image
Architect Philip Flockhart on Atholl Crescent. He has questioned EWH’s hiring of a ‘spin doctor’ | MSA Studio

But campaigners said that the development “risks undermining the architectural coherence and residential character of a key part of Edinburgh’s World Heritage Site.

There are also concerns about the leadership and direction of EWH after Mr Levinthal questioned whether Edinburgh still deserved its World Heritage status. The comments came at an event promoted by a pro-tourism body, further fuelling accusations that the organisation is aligning itself too closely with commercial interests rather than acting as an independent guardian of the city’s historic environment.

Mr Flockhart added: “There is a growing sense that Edinburgh World Heritage has lost sight of its core purpose. Its mission is to protect and enhance the city’s Outstanding Universal Value – not to justify poor judgement in planning matters or to promote developments that erode it.”

Last week, the campaigners said concerns regarding over-tourism risked the city’s UNESCO status risks being 'undermined'.

A decision on the hostel application is expected later this month (JUL) from a Reporter with the Scottish Government’s Planning and Environmental Appeals Division.

The plans drew 280 objections from local residents and heritage organisations – such as the Cockburn Association and Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, as well as the opposition of all four councillors for City Centre ward.

Edinburgh World Heritage has been approached for comment.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice