Edinburgh North-South tramline: Councillors say decision already made not to build northern section

‘There is no majority support for the northern section of this route’ - Cllr Chas Booth

The northern section of Edinburgh's proposed new North-South tramline will not go ahead, councillors have claimed.

The city's transport committee is not due to take a decision on the planned line from Granton to the Royal Infirmary and beyond until September when it will be presented with the strategic business case for the project.

A decision on the North-South tramline is due to be taken in September. placeholder image
A decision on the North-South tramline is due to be taken in September. | LISA FERGUSON

But Green transport spokesman Chas Booth told a meeting of the committee on Thursday that a decision had effectively been made already because of the stances adopted by the political groups.

He said: "We recognise there is no majority support [on the committee] for the northern section of this route. From our perspective it's regrettable that a decision on that has effectively been taken without having all of the evidence in front of us."

Tory group leader Iain Whyte also said there was already a "de facto decision" on the northern section.

The SNP, the biggest party currently with 15 councillors, announced during the Holyrood election campaign that it was opposed to both the Roseburn Path and Orchard Brae options for the route between Granton and the city centre and suggested work should start on the southern section while officials tried to find an alternative route for the northern section.

The Lib Dems, with 14 councillors, have made clear their opposition to the Roseburn Path route.

And the Conservatives, who have 10 councillors, are expected to oppose the new tramline altogether. That adds up to 39 councillors opposing the northern section out of a total of 63.

The committee agreed to SNP, Lib Dem and Green calls for the business case in September to set out costs and options for prioritising or proceeding with separate sections of the route.

In the public consultation on the new tramline, 53 per cent were opposed to the scheme as a whole, against 40 per cent in favour; 68 per cent opposed the Roseburn Path option, while 23 per cent supported it; 44 per cent opposed the Orchard Brae route, with 32 per cent in support; and 27 per cent opposed the city centre to Royal Infirmary route, with 51 per cent in favour.

The popular Roseburn Path is one of two route options for the tramline from Granton to the city centre. placeholder image
The popular Roseburn Path is one of two route options for the tramline from Granton to the city centre.

SNP councillor Danny Aston said those who responded to the consultation mostly agreed with his group's position.

He said: "If the business case looks positive, as we think and hope that it will, we think the southern leg is what we should proceed with.

"That's the part of the network where the patronage modelling looks best and it provides the greatest scope for connecting up with neighbouring local authorities and making this a truly regional project, which is a key criteria for the Scottish Government, potentially in terms of funding this.

"Taking the tram north or south is a process which will take many years and there simply isn’t the bandwidth to do simultaneously.

"This is a really, really important project. If it happens - and I hope it will - it will transform the way people move around our city. And the southern leg opens up the exciting possibility of connecting into tram trains on the South Sub."

Lib Dem transport spokesman Kevin Lang said the consultation had been one of the biggest the council had run in its history.

"There is unquestionably overwhelming opposition from the consultation respondents to the use of the Roseburn Path. There was also concern about using the Orchard Brae route, marginal support in favour of the southern leg, but overall you see a lot of concern about this proposal in its totality.

"I don't think that should come as any great surprise - so many people are still scarred by their experience of the first tramline, there is real concern over the impact it could have in certain communities, but also we have this unresolved question about how this will be funded."

The Conservatives had tabled an amendment calling for all work on the project's strategic business case to be halted as "a waste of taxpayer funds", but convener Stephen Jenkinson ruled it out of order.

Tory group leader Iain Whyte said: "We've had a very comprehensive consultation and the public say they are opposed to this, but no-one is going to listen to them. We're going to ignore them and continue spending money."

He said although the decision on going ahead with the project was to be made in September, money was already being spent. "We're spending money on officers and time and consultants that could be diverted to other things, like getting rid of some of the weeds or fixing the potholes or fixing the pavements.

"We should say no now because this is a costly process, burning through public money with no result."

Labour convener Stephen Jenkinson said the decision on the project would be taken in September.

He said: "I don't think any de facto decisions have been taken, I think we have to see all the data and the evidence along with the consultation at the right, appropriate time when the strategic business case is presented to the committee with all the options in front of us, to at that point make the decision how to proceed.

"I don't believe it's a waste of money to complete a piece of work that committee has already agreed to deliver. It would be a waste of money to not finish the job."

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice