Exclusive:Holyrood elections 2026: John Swinney on Edinburgh's new tramline, reopening South Sub and SNP seats at risk
Proposed new tramline ‘a local project’, says First Minister
John Swinney has said he is willing to “engage” with Edinburgh council on the proposed North-South tramline, but has insisted it is a “local project” which the council is responsible for.
And he blamed the trams for the slow progress on the dualling of the A9 between central Scotland and the Highlands, saying the funding of Edinburgh’s original tram project took money away from the road scheme.


In an exclusive interview with the Evening News, Mr Swinney did not explicitly rule out financial support for the new tramline from Granton to the Royal Infirmary and beyond, which is estimated to cost between £2 billion and £2.9 billion. But he hinted heavily that it would be up to the council to find the cash, pointing to the £207 million extension to Newhaven, completed in 2023 without government funding.
He said: “I'm very happy to engage with the city council about what their aspirations may be, but this is a local transport project. The Government has a pretty comprehensive range of national projects it will take forward.
“As the city council have demonstrated with the extension to Newhaven, this is a project that can be taken forward in the local context. I'm happy to talk to the city council but fundamentally it's a local project they need to take forward.
“What I've learned from all my experience of public sector projects is you have to be very clear about the leadership of who's involved. So just for the avoidance of doubt, I view this as something the city council is in the lead about. I’m happy for the government to engage, but the city council is in the lead.”
Pressed on funding, he said: “That's part of the issues we've got to consider. We have a capital programme that we've set out. The city council has a whole range of financial flexibilities available to them to develop projects and obviously we'd be happy to talk to the city council about them, should we be re-elected.”
The SNP election manifesto includes an explicit rejection of the Roseburn Path option for the northern part of the new tramline, in line with the position of the SNP group on the council, which has also rejected the alternative Orchard Brae route but has suggested work should start on the southern section of the line while a new route is found between Granton and the city centre.
And the manifesto also promises to commission a feasibility study on reopening the South Sub rail line to passenger services, using tram trains.
Asked about the party’s apparent willingness to commit to financial backing for the South Sub but not the tramline, Mr Swinney said: “There's a shared interest in making sure there's a strengthening public transport network because that is what we're going to need to help us to decarbonise transport and get to net zero. That type of shared agenda will help us to make the progress we're required to make, so I'm very happy to explore all these questions with the city council.
“The South Sub, as I understand it, would be a different character of project, so let me signal my willingness to engage but we have to be crystal clear about where leadership lies.”
Mr Swinney was Finance Secretary in 2007, when the SNP came to power as a minority government and wanted to abandon Edinburgh’s tram project. But the move was defeated by the opposition parties, and the government accepted the will of parliament and agreed to pay the money which had been promised.
Looking back, Mr Swinney said: “I didn’t think it was the best use of money. If I look at the pressure the government faces now about the A9, the reason why we're faced with challenges delivering more on the A9 is because we had to spend £500m on trams that I wanted to spend on the A9.
“And the people who are moaning about the A9 are the people that voted for the trams - Labour, Liberal, Conservative. The problem when you've got somebody with the experience I've got of public life, public policy, I don't forget much - and I remember who it was that wanted the trams and the £500m, who now forget the fact. They attacked me in 2007 for wanting to spend that money on the A9.
“I accepted the will of parliament all these years ago, but it’s just typical of the hypocrisy of many of my opponents who supported a completely opposite position in 2007 to the one they now adopt.”
Polls show the SNP on course to be comfortably the largest party in the Scottish Parliament after Thursday’s elections, but there are key seats in Edinburgh where the party is facing serious challenges. Culture Secretary Angus Robertson is under threat in Edinburgh Central, where the Greens claim boundary changes make the seat “very winnable” for them and where Labour have also been tipped as possible winners.
One poll also suggested Edinburgh North Eastern and Leith could go to the Greens. And the new Edinburgh Northern seat is seen as a close fight between the Lib Dems and the SNP.
Mr Swinney said: “Obviously there are going to be tightly contested constituencies in this election. What I would say to anyone who wants there to be progress in Scotland is they should vote for the SNP because we're the only party that is offering an agenda that will make sure there is a government that's always on Scotland's side, that is going to continue the improvements in the NHS, that is delivering tangible support on the cost of living, and also will put Scotland's future into Scotland's hands.
“And all our opponents are saying just now is ‘Vote for us to stop the SNP’. It’s a completely negative message and I think people today are looking for some hope and optimism and it's the SNP offers that. That’s why it’s important people come out and vote for the SNP, for an optimistic agenda about Scotland's future.”
On Mr Robertson, he said: “Angus is a precious colleague of mine and has contributed significantly to the government of Scotland. I obviously want to make sure Angus is re-elected - I've been supporting him in his constituency and his team is working really hard, as are other teams around the country.”