Simita Kumar: Stop scapegoating – migrants aren’t the problem

Raise your hand if you’re done with toxic politics and opportunistic blame games. Because I am.

Yet as your resident migrant turned healthcare worker turned councillor, I am, once again, having to wade into the very toxicity that turns so many people off politics.

Councillor Simita Kumar, SNP group leaderplaceholder image
Councillor Simita Kumar, SNP group leader

And while I truly wish I didn’t have to, I cannot allow Cllr Iain Whyte’s latest article to go unchallenged.

In his 8 August column in the Edinburgh Evening News, Cllr Whyte (Conservative goup leader in Edinburgh Council) astonishingly lays the blame for Edinburgh’s housing crisis at the feet of migrants. Yes, he goes there.

People crossing the English Channel in small boats make up a tiny fraction of total immigration (Picture: Ben Stansall/AFP via Getty Images)placeholder image
People crossing the English Channel in small boats make up a tiny fraction of total immigration (Picture: Ben Stansall/AFP via Getty Images)

He even admits he doesn’t “have space” to explain it all, but still confidently asserts that immigrants make up a “large part” of our homelessness problem. The absurdity of that statement is staggering.

Cllr Whyte and I will never see eye to eye on policies. That’s fine. But here’s what’s not: knowingly pushing harmful narratives that deflect from the truth.

Because Cllr Whyte knows the real facts. He knows migrants are not the cause of our housing emergency. He knows migrants are integral to our communities, our culture, our NHS, the very backbone of our society.

He knows that the fear of “small boats” is a manufactured distraction. And he definitely knows that the real political failure in Edinburgh isn’t a so-called “left-wing council” — it’s a right-wing alliance.

Yes, it’s the Tories who are propping up this Labour-led council. Their councillors are handsomely rewarded for doing so. Yet, when Cllr Whyte blames a ‘eft-wing majority’ for financial mismanagement, that’s not just misleading, it’s downright dishonest.

The truth? The council’s failings stem from political choices made by Labour, Tories,and Liberal Democrats working together.

And for transparency, Cllr Whyte, remind us, which budget you supported? Ah yes, the Labour one. So, is this public blame game just a warm-up act for a Reform UK audition?

Let’s not forget: it was the Tories under Thatcher who began selling off council houses, the architects of brutal austerity, who plunged millions into poverty, and rewarded the already- wealthy. And now?

Labour seems to outdo the Conservatives at their own game. From abandoning WASPI women and punishing disabled people to failing on housing and energy.

And what do they all have in common? Fear. Fear wins votes. They feed the public fear — of migrants, of “small boats,” of the fabricated enemy “stealing homes.”

But here’s what I ask of you: Please - don’t buy into it. The Edinburgh and the Scotland I know is built on community, compassion and fairness. We don’t need scapegoats. We need real leadership. We need vision, not vilification.

Let’s stop blaming people simply trying to survive. If you want to be angry about housing, be angry at the oligarchs, the bankers and landlords buying up entire streets, not the asylum seeker.

This isn’t about left or right anymore. It’s about right and wrong.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice