Waning coffee shops offer retail an opportunity - Kevin Buckle

I was sad to hear that near neighbours the Tinderbox Espresso Bar in Waverley Market are closing tomorrow. I’m not a coffee aficionado so am equally happy buying my coffee from a small shop or a chain and tend to base my choice more on those serving the coffee than the actual taste.

Starbucks in the centre is handily placed just off the Waverley Steps and has a core staff that are very friendly to both regulars and the many passers by.

Coffee giant Starbucks has applied for permission to install a new sign at its Ilkley branchplaceholder image
Coffee giant Starbucks has applied for permission to install a new sign at its Ilkley branch

I got on well with the Tinderbox staff too, but in terms of location what seems like a great site at the busiest entrance to Waverley Market on Waverley Bridge has in fact a fatal flaw for a coffee shop in that for anybody standing just yards away on the corner of Princes Street what they see is Costa in front of them and Black Sheep Coffee opposite.

This fatal flaw is of course mitigated when the Christmas Market is on as people leave the market opposite the Waverley Market Bridge entrance and the first coffee shop they can see is Tinderbox. It has been no surprise to see how busy they have been in recent weeks.

I’ve heard that already there are other coffee shops interested in taking over the site but I hope the centre’s owners see that while it is an excellent site in many respects, it is far more suited to retail than to being in competition with other coffee shops.

Coffee shops in general now seem to be struggling and Coca Cola are in talks with Asda’s owners TDR Capital in an attempt to sell Costa, which they bought from Premier Inn owner Whitbread in a £3.9bn deal.

It is now thought Coca Cola are prepared to sell for almost half the price they paid, which is a mind-blowing loss no matter how big a business may be.

Starbucks in the centre is doing well I hear and didn’t even seem to be affected when they also opened in the St James Centre. But generally with closures in the south of England and over 400 stores closing in the States, the omens are not good.

Starbucks have identified issues on several fronts and are looking to turn things around, which at least is more positive than Coca Cola’s attempt to sell Costa.

The Waverley Market also has a Costa, of course, at its Princes Street entrance and I’ve never been convinced that this is good for the centre in general, having what is a fantastic location and then blocking the main entrance with a coffee shop.

It was a situation the owners inherited when they bought the centre in 2017 and though I should be able to remember, I can’t say what was there before Costa.

This year’s footfall figures for the centre are great at just under seven and a half million, which is a 9.1 per cent increase on the previous year and compares very favourably with the overall figure for Scotland, which is down 1.4 per cent and the UK figure, which shows a very small increase of 0.4 per cent.

As Avalanche has shown, if you can match that footfall selling things people want, a business can do well. Coffee, however, is obviously not something customers struggle to find.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice