Why the strange silence over Edinburgh’s economic success? - Donald Anderson

It’s perhaps an odd question, but the continuing lack of any national debate about Edinburgh’s success is quite remarkable.

Just this week, leading data scientist and commentator on urban economics Dr Tom Forth highlighted the latest Office for National Statistics data, which showed that since 1999 economic growth measured as GDP per capita was 56.7 per cent in East Central Scotland, compared to London at 38.2 per cent and Manchester at 35.9 per cent.

Dr Tom Forth highlighted the latest Office for National Statistics data, which showed that since 1999 economic growth measured as GDP per capita was 56.7 per cent in East Central Scotlandplaceholder image
Dr Tom Forth highlighted the latest Office for National Statistics data, which showed that since 1999 economic growth measured as GDP per capita was 56.7 per cent in East Central Scotland

That’s an astonishing figure and West Central Scotland’s (Glasgow’s) success was also highlighted as being just behind London’s at 37.7 per cent - also ahead of Manchester’s.

This news was completely unnoticed in the Scottish political debate, as has Edinburgh’s success generally.

I do remember the one unique occasion I heard a significant political figure outside the city highlighting Edinburgh’s success. Andrew Wilson is a former SNP MSP, key government adviser and one of the sharpest minds to have walked the corridors of Holyrood. Back in 2019 he was speaking at a seminar hosted by Edinburgh University entitled Edinburgh Dialogues.

The story was written up in the News the next day. Wilson rightly spoke of his dismay at the quality of the economic debate about our cities by recalling his attendance at a Tartan Week event in Washington where the “Provosts of Edinburgh and Glasgow stood up to speak and slagged each other off and sat down to bemused crowd of senators.” Neither of the Provosts I worked with I hasten to add – they were never so stupid.

He went on to say that “For Scotland to succeed we need to stop thinking of Edinburgh as one of 32 local authorities and we need to regard it as our only capital, our premier world city and the epicentre of national economic life and we need to back Edinburgh to succeed unequivocally.”

He went on to call for the size of the city to double and for increased migration to help achieve that. Doubling the size of the city isn’t going to happen under any circumstances, but I was surprised at the scale of the ambition, however unrealistic.

More recently Michael Marra, the new Labour Leader at Holyrood, himself adept at economic figures and a breath of fresh air in the Scottish political debate, praised Manchester and said that if Scotland’s regions had grown at Manchester’s pace our economy would be up to £33 billion larger.

Two things are striking. First, no government figure since Andrew has ever set out an ambition for Edinburgh to be actively promoted as Scotland’s greatest economic asset. Indeed, Andrew himself has never returned to the subject. And Michael Marra didn’t pick up on the fact that the Edinburgh City Region has succeeded far more impressively than Greater Manchester has since devolution as the figures highlighted by Dr Tom Forth show.

I recall when the Chamber of Commerce invited Andy Burnham to speak to it about Manchester’s success – and he spoke well. I commented to the Chamber that perhaps Andy should be inviting Edinburgh down to show Manchester how it’s done – I wasn’t joking.

Edinburgh’s success stands comparison with London, which is remarkable, and Manchester, which is hugely creditable given that both those cities get more and better government support than Edinburgh has ever had. However, just don’t expect anyone senior in Scottish politics to say so any time soon.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice