Windfarm fears for safety of seabirds - Miles Briggs
People across the Lothians are well used to being the subject of the SNP’s desire for abundant renewable energy. Right across the region large onshore windfarms can be spotted across various hillsides and skylines.
Views are split, but in my experience there is a general understanding that we all have to play our part if energy is to be cleaner, more reliable and the source of well-paid, skilled jobs.


However, the largest project yet in this area is causing unprecedented concern.
Once complete, the Berwick Bank offshore windfarm off the East Lothian coast will be one of the largest in the world. It will also be one of the deadliest.


The developer’s own analysis shows thousands of seabirds will be killed each year and campaigners have warned some will be driven to local extinction.
These birds aren’t just a much-loved and treasured feature of life in East Lothian. They are crucial to the habitat and eco-system, and all of this now seems in grave jeopardy as a direct result of the project.
And it’s not just seabirds in danger – there will be risks to whales, dolphins, seals and fish.
The Scottish Government waved this through without proper scrutiny and since it was granted permission last summer new guidance has come into force.
For example, it allows developers to use “strategic” compensation for the environmental impact they cause.
This is akin to a business chopping down thousands of trees in one part of the country then vaguely promising to invest in unspecific carbon-neutral projects in another.
It’s no wonder local people remain totally unconvinced by this supposed assurance.
The Scottish Government makes the point that projects like Berwick Bank are important infrastructure and help the country – and indeed the planet – achieve net zero goals.
But if ministers think that thousands of birds each year deserve to be sacrificed for this, they should at least admit as much.
The issue with Berwick Bank isn’t merely the presence of a large renewables project.
It’s the lack of accountability and scrutiny and the apparent absence of concern shown by all involved to the unintended consequences.
The people of East Lothian have proved they are happy to host important renewable energy projects.
But that shouldn’t be interpreted by the Scottish Government as a willingness to roll over just because important ministers have lined themselves up with a huge renewables company.
Before these plans go any further, the government must pledge to set out exactly what’s being done to protect these birds, conserve our local ecology, and ensure this project goes ahead with the blessing – not the antagonism - of local communities.