‘It’s becoming a theme park’: Residents hit out as second apart-hotel on Forth Street approved
At a council planning meeting residents raised concerns about the impact of more tourist accommodation on the character of the New Town
Residents who live on Forth Street in Edinburgh’s New Town have warned the city centre is at risk of becoming like a “theme park” after plans for a second apart-hotel on the street were approved by councillors.
The proposals will see the 19th-century terraced houses at 16 - 26 Forth Street, which are currently used as offices, converted into a 53-bed apartment complex with a “hotel type” reception and facilities.
But residents have said those who live on the street "unanimously oppose” the development, warning the addition of more visitor accommodation threatens the residential character of the area.
“I’m hugely disappointed,” said Janice Donaldson, who has lived on the street for 37 years.
“I already live on a street where an apart-hotel, Forth House, takes up half the street. We’re swamped with hotels here.
“We’ve got a really good community, and a lot of my neighbours have lived here for a long time.
“The people who work in the offices added to that sense of community because you got to know them, whereas these new transient visitors won’t add anything.”
She continued: “There’s a wider question here about what we want for our city centre.
“Do we want it to be filled with people with trolley bags, or do we want it to be somewhere where people actually live?
“It’s becoming a theme park.”
.jpg?trim=237,0,0,0&width=640&quality=65)

Giovanni Fappiano, who has lived on the street for 23 years, said he agreed the amount of hotels in the area had become “too much”.
“They’re everywhere you turn,” the 77-year-old said. “I’m particularly worried about parking. Parking is already a nightmare. You have to drive round and round to find a space.
“The extra number of visitors will surely only make that worse.”
Speaking at the council meeting on Wednesday morning, Chair of the Picardy Place Residents' Association Peter Williamson said if the plans went ahead the combined number of visitors staying on the street could be up to five times the number of people who live there as residents.
On top of that, he said there were over 1,000 rooms already operating for visitors within a 300-metre radius of the property.
Following the meeting, he said: “It goes without saying that for local residents the outcome is deeply disappointing. After the meeting of the Development Management Sub Committee, residents’ serious concerns remain.
“For them, I find it disappointing that their voice did not carry more weight in the whole application process. This was compounded by the fact that the objection ultimately had no support from any committee members to force a vote.
“The outcome for me highlights that such matters are always decided on a one off-basis without adequate reference to wider considerations of where Edinburgh wishes to go with visitor accommodation.
“Its impact is not neutral for residents living in the areas affected. This needs more recognition and development of policies by the City Council that are more attuned to the position of residents.”
In June, developers Limetree Developments (West) Limited decided to scale down the number of hotel units from 92 to 53, which the firm said would significantly reduce footfall, traffic and activity in the area.
The redesigns removed an on-site bar and restaurant, and featured revised floorplans following concerns raised by Historic Environment Scotland (HES) about changes to the layout of the building’s principle rooms and the visibility of the decorative ceilings and other architectural features.
HES neither supports or opposes the plans, but Edinburgh World Heritage said the rear extension in particular continued to be “objectionable” and eroded the traditional pattern of buildings found in the New Town.
Fraser Marwick, Director of Limetree, said: "We are delighted that the Committee has granted our application.
“Throughout this process, we have worked closely and constructively with Council officers to design a high-quality scheme that respects the building's architectural heritage and minimises impacts on the local community.
"As our development progresses, we remain fully committed to ongoing engagement with the neighbouring residents and wider community."
