Scottish Government council shake-up plans 'amateurish' and 'doomed to fail'
Transport convener Stephen Jenkins weighs in on reform proposals
Scottish Government's plans to shake-up Scotland's councils have been labelled "amateurish" and "doomed to fail".
Edinburgh transport convener Stephen Jenkinson said he was "supportive of change" but complained the government was going the wrong way about it.
Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth published initial proposals last week to replace Scotland's current 32 councils with between six and 10 new regional authorities and, within them, up to 160 community authorities, with Leith cited as an example of places which could get their own community authority.


Cllr Jenkinson said there were "obvious opportunities" in a regional approach on matters like transport and planning. He said: "I can see the benefit of the regional aspect of this. But at the other end, I think people would struggle to see the logic of breaking up Scotland's capital city from a local government perspective.”
And he accused the government of sidelining councils by its approach. Ministers have not fleshed out their proposals and have set a three-month timetable, ending in early December, for the conversation with councils and others.
Cllr Jenkinson said: “I’m quite supportive of change, but I don't think it's right, the approach the government is taking - basically sidelining local government.”
And he backed comments made by Edinburgh council leader Jane Meagher, who branded the government’s approach “an insult to local democracy” and warned the proposed scheme would mean Edinburgh council would “cease to exist”.
Cllr Jenkinson’s remarks came after he posted on social media, outlining his concerns about the government plans.
He wrote: “I can see areas where reform could genuinely help us deliver better services. Transport is an obvious example. People don’t live their lives within council boundaries.
“Our roads, buses, railways and major infrastructure connect communities across Edinburgh, the Lothians, Fife and the wider region. There is a strong case for looking at how we strengthen regional strategic transport planning and, crucially, our ability to actually deliver major infrastructure across council boundaries.
“So I’m not against reforming local government. Far from it. But reform of this scale has to be developed with local government — not done to local government.
“What we’ve seen so far from the Scottish Government feels rushed, poorly thought through and, frankly, slightly amateurish. We should be having a serious discussion about what problems we are trying to solve, what should remain genuinely local, where regional working could deliver better results and what powers and resources councils need to make that happen.
“Instead, councils appear to have been presented with a process rather than involved in designing it. If Ministers genuinely want reform to succeed, they need to stop treating Scotland’s councils as an afterthought and start working with them as partners.
“Because right now, instead of building the consensus needed to deliver meaningful and lasting change, this process looks increasingly doomed to fail. Reform can be an opportunity. But you don’t strengthen local democracy by sidelining local government.”
In a debate on the proposals in the Scottish Parliament earlier this week, Public Finance Minister Hannah Mary Goodlad told MSPs that the current conversations with councils were “the start of a consultation period that will lay the blueprint and the foundation”, and that “conversations and dialogue” would continue after Christmas.