Hearts data gem turns Edinburgh Derby queen as inspired hat-trick vs Hibs clinches Capital Cup triumph
Venezuelan striker’s hat-trick proves decisive as Hearts retain Capital Cup and claim Edinburgh Derby bragging rights
Andy Thomson credited Jamestown Analytics for identifying Marianne Speckmaier after the Venezuelan striker bagged a decisive hat-trick to give Hearts a thrilling 3-2 victory over rivals Hibs and take the Capital Cup back to Gorgie.
Speckmaier completed her treble after 69 minutes at Easter Road to help the Jambos claim the first Edinburgh Derby bragging rights of the season and give head coach Thomson a memorable introduction to the historic fixture following his appointment in the summer.
Thomson was effusive in his praise of the Miami-born 28-year-old, signed from Durham FC on a one-year deal, and lauded the club’s data-driven recruitment model for unearthing the talented forward, after initially viewing Speckmaier as more of a wide player.


“Thanks to Jamestown for that,” Thomson smiled when asked about Speckmaier’s vital contribution. “I felt that Marianne was coming on to that type of performance, slowly getting used to the way we want to play. She’s maybe not made the most of some of her opportunities in previous games, but she’s up there as top goal scorer for a reason.
“That was vindicated with her performance today and she thoroughly deserved her three goals. She was great, not just in terms of her goals, but her overall work rate and effort was excellent and she’s getting rewarded for it.
“When I first watched her, she played more as a winger but I felt she could play more centrally,” he added. “She possesses some unusual movement at times and probably likes to run down the channels too much. I want her to be positioned in the centre of the box and we’ll continue to work on that.
“But today was more about running those chances and finding spaces, which I thought she exploited really well. I thought this was the game she would excel in and she produced a real top-class performance and perhaps should’ve scored more. I’m really pleased with her.”
The first Edinburgh Derby of the campaign lived up to its billing, with the momentum shifting throughout a pulsating contest before Hearts held on under intense late pressure. There was added intrigue surrounding the contest, with spectators offered free tickets and hospitality as part of continued efforts to grow the profile of women’s football in Scotland.
How the match unfolded
Despite their Europa Cup exploits against Real Sociedad in midweek, Hearts made the brighter start and came close to breaking the deadlock after seven minutes. Speckmaier found herself in space on the left side of the box, only for Faye Bryson to block her effort from a tight angle.
Bryson then nearly turned provider at the other end, clipping the top of the crossbar with what appeared to be an attempted cross as the game began to open up.
It was Hearts who made the breakthrough after 23 minutes when Mairead Fulton whipped a dangerous free-kick into a crowded penalty area from the left, and Speckmaier stretched to make contact, with her faint touch enough to direct the ball beyond Eve Annets, who was making only her second start since arriving on loan from Manchester City.
Hibs responded strongly and should have levelled when Aoife Colvill was picked out following a flowing move involving Rachael Boyle, but the forward dragged her effort narrowly wide.
Colvill redeemed herself moments later. In the 32nd minute, parity was restored with a superb finish. Boyle’s cross was only partially cleared and Bryson cushioned a header down into Colvill’s path. The Hibs attacker showed great strength to hold off her opponent before turning inside and sweeping an excellent finish into the top-left corner.
But Hearts had the final say before the interval. A defensive blunder from Siobhan Hunter allowed the visitors to regain the lead in the 44th minute after Jess Husband’s raking pass split the Hibs defence. Speckmaier raced through one-on-one with Annets before keeping her composure to slot beyond the advancing keeper into the bottom-right corner.
Hearts’ seized control in the 69th minute as they opened a two-goal cushion. Speckmaier completed her hat-trick in rather fortuitous fashion after Kayla Jardine’s deflected cross looped high into the air and meant Annets could only palm the ball into the experienced forward’s path to tap into an empty net from a few yards out. Hibs appealed for offside, but the goal stood.


To their credit, Joelle Murray’s side refused to surrender. Substitute Kyah Simon hada free-kick tipped around the post by Thomson after it took a wicked deflection. But their pressure paid off with nine minutes remaining.
The lively Colvill produced another moment of individual brilliance, unleashing a stunning volley from around 25 yards beyond Thomson, who had no chance as Hearts failed to properly clear another delivery into their box.
Hearts were reduced to ten in stoppage time when Ellen Dolan received a second yellow card for conceding a needless free-kick in a dangerous position. But Hibs were unable to muster up an equaliser despite a valiant late surge.
Murray: ‘I know we are far better than that’
Deflated Hibs boss Murray felt her side failed to show their true quality and suggested the occasion may have got to some of her players.
She admitted: “It’s really disappointing because we know the girls can give us more than they showed today. We’ve watched them train to a higher level and with much more quality every single day. I know we are far better than that and that’s probably my main frustration.
“Perhaps it was nerves, playing at an unfamiliar stadium where maybe only a handful of the girls have played here before. But we certainly didn’t live up to the levels that we know they’re capable of. When you dissect the goals we concede, I don’t think Hearts had to work relatively hard for them.”