The Scottish Premiership welcomes players from all over the world, and while so go on to become world-class stars, others fail to live up to the expectation previously set for them. Playing on the Scottish shores can be a completely different kettle of fish than anywhere else with current Hearts’ star Calem Nieuwenhof recently detailing how much more physical the play is here compared to his home down under.
Many who have signed for the Jambos have gone on to shine under these conditions but there are even more who have struggled with this skill set and failed to impress when their boss required. This does not, of course, mean the upcoming list of players who didn’t work out at Hearts are bad players. In fact, in most cases it is far from it. But Gorgie has not worked out for everyone, for whatever reason, and here are 25 of those such players who couldn’t quite get it together for the Jambos.

9. Lennard Sowah
Didn't bode well that Hamilton Accies fans were puzzled as to why Hearts wanted to sign him. Struggled defensively and didn't show much going forward. Photo: SNS Group Rob Casey

10. Choulay
Perhaps the most forgettable signing of the window. The loanee winger mainly played as a substitute and was ineffective. Photo: SNS Group Rob Casey

11. Malaury Martin
Signed on a four-year deal and advertised as a set-piece specialist. Wasn't particularly great at set-pieces save for one free-kick goal and only spent six months in the first-team before disappearing from sight. Was still a Hearts player for two years after. Photo: SNS Group Alan Rennie

12. Rafal Grzelak
An industrious full-back. Not particularly adept on the ball and prone to errors defensively. Photo: SNS Group Roddy Scott

