Alan Shearer makes VAR demand after key Hearts title race call as Ally McCoist claims situation a 'car crash'

The Newcastle United and Rangers legends have reacted after a night of high drama involving Hearts.

Alan Shearer has called for the removal of VAR after incidents impacting the English Premier League and Scottish Premiership title races.

Down south last weekend, West Ham’s equalising goal against Arsenal was ruled out for a foul by Pablo on David Raya after a lengthy VAR check. It deepened their relegation fears and allowed the Gunners to keep glory dreams within their grasps and quickly the refereeing microscope has transferred to Scotland after Celtic’s controversial penalty versus Motherwell. Hearts currently sit top of the table with the defending champions beneath them ahead of a final day showdown at Parkhead.

Ref John Beaton was called to the monitor deep into second half stoppage time for a review, after VAR official Andrew Dallas flagged up a possible handball by Motherwell Sam Nicholson, when jumping to header the ball. His challenge against Auston Trusty was deemed handball, a penalty was awarded, and Celtic scored to win 3-2. It means instead of having to win by three goals against Hearts to pip them into first place, the Hoops now simply have to win by any margin, after swapping a three-point deficit for one.

Alan Shearer on VAR within football

Responding to an article analysing how VAR has impacted title races, Shearer made his demands clear amid controversies impacting Hearts. He said on X: “But we were told it was for absolute howlers ONLY and they WONT re referee and maximum benefit and minimum interference!!! #GETRIDOFIT”

Rangers legend Ally McCoist has been watching on and the ex-Scotland striker is saddened by how the situation has left the Scottish game looking amid a wider audience. Hearts are pushing for their first top flight title since 1960 while aiming to become the maiden club since Aberdeen in 1985 to bring glory outside of Glasgow’s top two.

He told talkSPORT Bet: “I'm really not sure it has [divided opinion] because the vast majority of people that I speak to think it was an absolutely shocking decision. I think I’ll take it a step further. I think the use of VAR has embarrassed Scottish football. You know, for the guys in control to think that is a clear and obvious error is absolutely remarkable. Remarkable.

Ally McCoist on Celtic penalty vs Motherwell

“And then, for the referee who has got previous with Celtic supporters, let's not forget that, he's got previous Celtic supporters and not in a good way, goes over and makes the decision after 15 seconds or so, it's just a car crash really. It's an absolute car crash.

“When you get people down south looking at it and using the words cheating, it's such a shame because I don't mind telling you, it probably has tarnished the Scottish Premiership title ever so slightly in my opinion because no matter what happens at the weekend we'll be talking about this decision I think for a long long time. Very sad.

“There's no doubt, the fact that Hearts have already beat Celtic twice, beat Rangers three times and drawn once would indicate they've got absolutely nothing to be scared of. You would rather be the team at home, that goes without saying. But the fact of the matter is, Hearts have got to travel to Celtic Park, they've done it before, and Derek McInnes will be reminding his players that that's the case. So, yes, you would rather be playing the game at home, of course you would, but it's not the be all and end all.”

The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice