Edinburgh speeding: Readers mostly hostile to idea of volunteers with speed guns

A call for Edinburgh to consider recruiting community volunteers to use speed guns to monitor motorists has met with a largely hostile reaction from Evening News readers.

Community Speedwatch schemes are well-established in some places south of the border and one has been trialled in Fife.

Members of the public volunteer to be trained in the use speed guns. And they dress in high visibility clothing to record details of speeding vehicles - registration numbers, speeds, dates, and times - which are then passed to the police, who issue warning letters. Repeat offenders can face prosecution based on collected evidence.

A Community Speedwatch volunteer in action in Northamptonshireplaceholder image
A Community Speedwatch volunteer in action in Northamptonshire

Green councillor Chas Booth successfully proposed at the last meeting of Edinburgh's transport committee that officials should look at the possibility of operating such a scheme in the Capital.

He said speeding was a contributory factor in one in three fatal crashes, but Police Scotland was not doing enough to enforce speed limits.

"In the absence of effective measures to tackle speeding from the police, the council should explore alternatives to tackle the issue. Community Speedwatch is one such initiative, which has worked in other parts of the country and could work in Edinburgh too."

But after the story appeared in the Evening News on Saturday, readers posted their views on Facebook.

One said: "Sounds a bit Gestapo like .... Snooping and grassing your neighbour."

Another said: "This is a police matter. No one should be monitoring except the police. And they need a much larger presence out on the roads."

And a third posted: "Recruit a local jobsworth with nothing better to do, and give them a high-vis vest and a speed gun! Couldn't make it up."

The Community Speedwatch national organisation has rejected accusations that the scheme is "policing-on-cheap" "waging war on motorists" or "retired people with nothing better to do".

It says: "Speedwatch activity is not about interfering with neighbours' behaviour; it is a proactive solution to improve the safety and quality of life for everyone in their local community."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice