Edinburgh's North-South tramline: Northern section likely to be shelved amid controversy over Roseburn Path plans

‘There is no majority for using the Roseburn Path and the Orchard Brae option isn't realistic’ - council insider

The northern section of Edinburgh's proposed new North-South tramline looks likely to be shelved due to disagreements over the route.

Councillors are due to vote next month on whether to take forward the Capital's latest tram project, costed at between £2 billion and £2.9 billion for the full line from Granton to the Royal Infirmary and the BioQuarter.

But there has been fierce controversy over the plan to route the line along the popular Roseburn Path. And the alternative Orchard Brae proposal is widely viewed as too much of an engineering challenge since it would involve taking trams across the historic Dean Bridge.

The section of the proposed tramline from Granton to the city centre may be shelved placeholder image
The section of the proposed tramline from Granton to the city centre may be shelved

During the Scottish Parliament elections in May, the SNP announced it supported a North-South line, but opposed both the Roseburn Path and Orchard Brae options and wanted work to start on the southern section while council officials tried to find another route for the northern part.

The Lib Dems are firmly opposed to the use of Roseburn Path and sceptical about the whole project because of lack of funding. And Conservative councillors have voted repeatedly against the project.

The Greens and the minority Labour administration are in favour of the new line, but have not taken a position on which northern route it should follow.

The Roseburn Path, a former railway line. is now a popular walking and cycling route placeholder image
The Roseburn Path, a former railway line. is now a popular walking and cycling route

One council insider said: "There is no majority for using the Roseburn Path and the Orchard Brae option isn't realistic. It seems likely they are going to end up looking at splitting the route and going with the south line only at this stage. I think that's where the administration is at - it accepts that the northern line is just too problematic."

And another source said: “Everyone recognises that whatever plan emerges on the new tramline, it is going to be the result of negotiation and compromise. But the administration wants to proceed with the project and they’re not going to kill it off if there’s an option to go ahead with at least part of the line for now.”

A key question, however, will be whether going ahead with just the southern section of the route, from Princes Street to the Royal Infirmary and the BioQuarter, would add up financially.

That is one of the issues expected to be addressed when the council’s transport and environment committee is presented next month with the strategic business case for the North-South line, drawn up by council officials and setting out the costs and benefits of building the new line.

It is expected officials will back the Roseburn Path option since that was their preferred route before the committee decided Orchard Brae should also be considered.

The committee will also have to address the question of paying for the project. The Scottish Government has been reluctant to offer any financial support, with First Minister John Swinney telling the Evening News in May that the new tramline was “a local project” which the council needed to take forward.

The council has been in talks with the UK Government’s National Wealth Fund, but said the discussions had been purely advisory.

If the committee agrees to take the project forward it could be made “subject to securing the necessary funding”.

Northern route was seen as crucial

The northern section of the line, between Granton and the city centre, was seen as vital new infrastructure because of the thousands of homes being built there as part of the area’s £1.3 billion regeneration programme.

And the Roseburn Path a former railway line, was the route approved by the Scottish Parliament as part of the legislation for Edinburgh’s original tram project in 2006. But that was before it gained its current popularity as a well-used walking and cycle path.

The council said a reduced path would still be provided alongside the tram, but the Save Roseburn Path campaign has made a sustained argument against the loss of a valuable green space and an oasis of calm.

The campaign insists there is “no workable compromise” that can protect the Roseburn Path as a linear park, active travel route and wildlife corridor. And it claims the loss of the Roseburn Path would put at risk Edinburgh’s entire path network.

Advocates of the Roseburn Path route argue it would be cheaper and less disruptive to build because it would not involve digging up roads and diverting utility pipes and cables.

They say it would also get people to the city centre more quickly and provide a new public transport link to the Western General Hospital and the Craigleith retail park.

The public consultation showed 68 per cent opposition to using the Roseburn Path for trams and just 23 per cent support, though separate market research put the opposition at 23 per cent and support at 43 per cent.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice