I watched Scotland's 1990 Grand Slam from Roseburn end - will it top fans' poll of Murrayfield moments?

Celebrate the grand old ground’s 100th anniversary by voting for your personal highlight

The experts all have their favourites, of course. There will also be a degree of recency bias when it comes to fans casting their votes.

But surely there can only be one winner, right? When the Scottish rugby-loving public vote on the greatest moment in 100 years of Murrayfield, it’s hard to look beyond one particular game.

As someone who has actually there on the terracing for Scotland’s 1990 Grand Slam-clinching victory over England, it feels like there is only one choice. Yes, even though I was also there to witness one of the other beautiful moments – a day of unrivalled emotion – short-listed by the all-star panel of Sir Ian McGeechan, Chris Paterson, Mike Blair and Dee Bradbury.

Ian McGeechan was coach for Grand Slam glory

Sir Ian was coach in 1990, Paterson remains Scotland’s most-capped player with 109 appearances for his country, Blair is a former captain who represented the British and Irish Lions – and Bradbury, also a former player – was the first women to be elected as president of Scottish Rugby. Having been overwhelmed by responses to their request for nominations, Scottish Rugby are now asking supporters to cast the final vote. So let’s look at the options.

Sending them homeward tae think again … the 1990 Slam

This is personal for those of us who just happened to be hitting the perfect age for watching sport - and celebrating glorious victories in the pub afterwards – just as the new decade rolled around. What a day for anyone lucky enough to be there.

Now, I didn’t actually see Tony Stanger touching the ball down for arguably the most famous try in Scottish rugby history. A lack of inches, the gentle slope of the old Roseburn terracing AND trying to watch through a forest of arms raised in premature celebration certainly contributed to a restricted view.

Team captain David Sole (wearing a tartan tammy) leads the squad off the pitch at Murrayfield after their win.placeholder image
Team captain David Sole (wearing a tartan tammy) leads the squad off the pitch at Murrayfield after their win.

But the whole day was incredible. And the excitement started weeks and weeks in advance, as a couple of us got together at 4 am on a Saturday morning to queue for tickets (no internet, no phone line) outside of an Edinburgh sports shop, the queue snaking from George Street down Frederick Street.

On the day of the game itself, it took a strong will to knock back the increasingly crazy offers – hundreds and hundreds of pounds - for tickets that cost just £6 each. If we’d taken the cash and invested it wisely, it might have been worth a pretty penny today. But it would have meant missing out on a priceless experience.

From David Sole’s slow walk out of the tunnel to the big hits, Stanger’s try and a heroic goal-line stand, the whole day was a ridiculous riot of colour, noise and joy. Having watched the 1984 Grand Slam from the sofa, the real thing was absolutely incredible.

Paterson, who has experienced a few highs in his rugby life, said: “That’s the moment in my lifetime. It was pure theatre, and linked to arguably Scotland’s greatest success.”

McGeechan, coach on the day, recalled: “The atmosphere was spectacular. The supporters cheered every line-out, every kick, every tackle as if we’d scored.

“I still get shivers thinking about it. Bill McLaren said he couldn’t speak at the end of the game. There was a 30-second silence on television. Hearing that, it hit me that this was different.”

Doddie Weir brings 67,000 to tears

The game itself, a 22-17 loss to New Zealand in 2017, was outstanding. But all we really remember about this day is Doddie Weir, accompanied by his sons Hamish, Angus and Ben, delivering the match ball.

The big man had just been diagnosed with MND. And it would have taken a heart of stone not to well up as the former Scotland great, always one of the most popular figures in the game, was afforded an incredibly emotional ovation from the crowd.

placeholder image
SNS Group/SRU

“I was bawling my eyes out,” admitted Blair, who was assistant coach of Scotland at the time, the former scrum-half adding: “You could feel the emotion ripple around the stadium. Everyone was thinking of Doddie, his family, and their own loved ones.”

Bradbury added: “The roar when he walked onto that pitch was deafening. People were sobbing, the players on the pitch were wiping tears from their eyes, and Doddie was clearly very moved by everyone’s support. Just magical and humbling.”

How did they all fit in? The record crowd

Officially, there were 100,000 people crammed into Murrayfield as Scotland beat Wales 12-10 in March of 1975. But many will tell you that the number was closer to 130,000.

Explaining how different the fan experience was half a century ago, McGeechan recalled: “In those days, you just turned up, bought your ticket, and walked in – no pre-booking. The SRU never accepted it was 130,000 – but it was. People were worried about the numbers – children being lifted down over the barriers to sit by the pitch. You couldn’t imagine it now, but it was incredible to witness.

“I was playing that day, and one of the most enduring memories was the schoolboys sitting along the touchline, all in their uniforms as was the style. We stopped Wales winning the Grand Slam. You remember the way you felt, not just what happened. You see just how much something can have such an impact on you.”

The panel came up with a few honourable mentions that didn’t make the list, from Flower of Scotland making its Murrayfield debut in 1989 to that ’84 Slam and Finn Russell’s ‘pass of the century’ against England in 2018. Fans have until 5 pm on Monday, November 10 to cast their vote.

Can you really look beyond 1990? Let’s hear from you, then. And vote here: scottishrugby.org/murrayfieldmemories

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice