Dermot Gallagher

The decision severely dented Hearts' hopes of their first league title since 1960.

Ex referee thinks penalty that impacted Hearts didn't reach criteria

Hearts and Hibs decisions have been reviewed

Five Hearts and Hibs decisions handed the Ref Watch treatment

Josh Campbell put the game to bed with his late effort.

Referee gives verdict on Hibs VAR decisions against Ross County

Jack Milne's mistimed tackle on Beni Baningime was the subject of great debate.

Former referee makes scathing VAR admission after Hearts vs Hibs

Hibs' Mykola Kukharevych and Motherwell's Paul McGinn in action

Three Hibs vs Motherwell incidents put under ex-referees microscope

Referee David Dickinson checks VAR before awarding Rangers a penalty.

Rangers vs Hibs penalty gets Ref Watch treatment as verdict delivered

Referee Don Robertson checks the VAR monitor for a handball by Celtic's Tomoki Iwata.

Hearts get the Ref Watch treatment after Celtic controversy

Hearts defender Alex Cochrane speaks to referee Nick Walsh after he is sent off against Celtic.

Gallagher and McCann disagree with ex Scottish refs on Cochrane red card

Hibs midfielder Jimmy Jeggo begins his walk off the pitch after his red card against St Johnston

Former refs have contrasting say on Jeggo red card

Élie Youan leaves the field of play following his red card for a second bookable offence involving Cameron Carter-Vickers, right.

Ex-player and ref have say on Celtic-Hibs flashpoints

Celtic claimed a penalty for handball against Michael Smith, but the VAR stuck with the referee's decision not to award a spot kick. Picture: Ross Parker / SNS

Ex-referee disagrees with Stewart on handball verdict v Celtic

Ryan Porteous appeals for a penalty after going down under Liam Scales' challenge

Ex-ref has say on Hibs penalty and handball claim against Dons

Former EPL referee Dermot Gallagher has had his say on Willie Collum's decision-making

Collum 'got Hibs and Rangers penalty calls right'

Hibs defender Ryan Porteous argues with referee Alan Muir after his sending-off against Aberdeen

Hibs unlikely to win Porteous appeal, claims ex-ref

Referee John Beaton awards Hibs a penalty and books St Johnstone's Jamie McCart during the match at Easter Road. Picture: SNS

Ex-EPL ref has say on Hibs penalty against St Johnstone

Guthrie scores to make it 2-0 but the goal shouldn't have stood says expert Gallagher (Photo by Ross MacDonald / SNS Group)

Why Livingston goal vs Hibs shouldn't have stood
Jon Guthrie’s goal for Livingston at Easter Road on Saturday should have been ruled out for offside, according to ex-English Premier League official Dermot Gallagher.
David Oliver

Hibernian's Joe Newell and Rangers' Connor Goldson during the Scottish Premiership match. (Photo by Rob Casey / SNS Group)

Why Hibs didn't get a penalty for Hagi's challenge at Ibrox

Steven Naismith and Celtic's Scott Brown battle for possession during Hearts' victory at Tynecastle. Picture: PA

Ex-Premier League referee has his say on Brown and Naismith incidents

News you can trust since 1873

© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Terms and Conditions Privacy notice